Takeaways
#- Verrone questioned whether the largest historical sample was always the most relevant one.
- A different long-term rate environment could change expectations about defensive sectors and market relationships.
- His uncertainty about near-term yields favored patience when shorter- and longer-term views did not align.
- He used alternative scenarios to keep testing a market hypothesis.
Chris Verrone was questioning a familiar research instinct: gather as much historical data as possible. A bigger sample could still be the wrong one if the market environment had changed.
In his May 30, 2024 Morning Show interview with JC Parets, Spencer Israel and Steve Strazza, Verrone described the problem through the bond market. Much of his career had taken place amid falling yields. That history had shaped expectations about defensive sectors and relationships between markets.
Which period fits the question?
If the long-term direction of rates had changed, Verrone wondered whether a narrower historical period might be more useful than the largest available sample. He raised 1952–1977 as an alternative to the period from 1977 through 2020.
He was not proposing that every feature of the 1970s would repeat. He pointed to utilities and consumer staples as an example of what deserved another look. In his reading of the late 1960s and 1970s, their temporary rallies had not made them reliable places to remain defensively positioned.
The question was whether assumptions learned during a long decline in yields would hold in a different environment.
Long-term and near-term views could differ
Verrone was less certain about the immediate path of yields. He thought the current rise might be the last move higher within that cycle, but did not know whether the 10-year Treasury yield would exceed its previous peak.
Weakness in consumer discretionary stocks and transports made him reluctant to expect yields to run sharply higher. When the shorter-term picture and the longer-term backdrop did not align, he preferred to step back and wait.
He also questioned the assumption that falling yields would necessarily be good news. As a hypothetical, he said a 10-year yield around 3.9% by September 30 could worry him: it might reinforce signs of an economic slowdown already suggested by those weaker equity groups.
Test the base case against alternatives
Verrone described a client's sequence of imagining an outcome, investigating it and then investing. The first step mattered because a working hypothesis needed constant refinement.
He asked Parets what would surprise him over the next year. Parets offered a failed gold breakout that returned price below its 2011 highs. Verrone approved of the reasoning: for a trend follower, a reversal against the prevailing trend should be more surprising than its continuation.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-05-30 episode.
Why did Verrone question using the longest backtest?
He wondered whether a large sample drawn from a different rate environment could be less useful than a narrower period that better resembled the market being studied.
What could make lower yields concerning?
He raised a hypothetical drop in the 10-year Treasury yield to around 3.9% by September 30. He thought it could reinforce slowdown concerns already suggested by weaker consumer discretionary stocks and transports.
How did he test a trend-following view?
He asked what outcome would be surprising. When Parets described a failed gold breakout, Verrone agreed that a move against the prevailing trend should be the greater surprise for a trend follower.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .