Takeaways
#- Sohn saw strength among restaurant stocks beyond the two large chains dominating the discussion.
- Equal weights would give smaller operators a clearer voice in the index; market-cap weights would give industry leaders more influence.
- The group proposed either excluding the biggest companies or retaining them with limits on their weights.
McDonald's and Starbucks were weak. CAVA, Texas Roadhouse and Wingstop were telling a different story. Todd Sohn wanted to know why the first two stocks should carry so much weight in the conversation about how American consumers were doing.
On the May 7, 2024 Morning Show, Sohn made the case for another way to track restaurant stocks. The problem started with the question investors were asking. If they wanted to know how the biggest chains were performing, looking at the biggest chains made sense. If they wanted to know whether weakness was spreading through the industry, those same stocks could obscure the answer.
What should count as a restaurant index?
Sohn remembered an equal-weight restaurant fund and wished someone would replace it. Giving each stock the same weight would keep a move in McDonald's from swamping what happened at smaller operators. When he looked beyond the largest names, he saw considerable strength.
The hosts raised an objection: restaurants differ in size and business model. An equal-weight index would give a small chain just as much influence as a company that had grown into an industry leader. A market-cap-weighted index rewarded that success by letting the more valuable company count for more.
They considered two alternatives. One was to use market-cap weights but exclude companies above a size limit. The hosts floated $50 billion and $30 billion as possible cutoffs. Another was to keep the biggest companies but cap their weights. The first approach would isolate a different group of restaurants. The second would still include McDonald's and Starbucks while leaving room for other chains to affect the result.
Which consumer was the stock supposed to represent?
Sohn wanted a look at smaller restaurant companies because they might offer clues about customers the national giants didn't represent well. That was a reason to look more closely at individual names before drawing a conclusion about spending. A weak McDonald's or Starbucks chart could sit alongside strength at Texas Roadhouse or Wingstop. For Sohn, the interesting part was precisely where their experiences differed.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-05-07 episode.
Why did Todd Sohn want a different restaurant benchmark?
Weak results at McDonald's and Starbucks were being read as a sign of consumer weakness. Stocks such as CAVA, Texas Roadhouse and Wingstop showed that the pattern did not extend to every chain.
What objection did the hosts raise to equal weighting?
A small restaurant company would influence the index as much as an established leader, even when the two had little in common.
How would a size cutoff differ from a weight cap?
A size cutoff would leave the largest companies out. A cap would keep them in the index while limiting how much their stocks could affect the result.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .