Takeaways

#
  • Balchunas argued that a fund’s fee should reflect how much its portfolio differs from inexpensive broad-market exposure.
  • He said lower fees were making some active managers more appealing to advisers.
  • The ETF structure can accommodate active management as well as index tracking.
  • He saw covered-call, defined-outcome and other differentiated strategies as ways for managers to offer something beyond a benchmark-like stock portfolio.

An active fund holding many of the same stocks as the S&P 500 faces a pricing problem: investors can buy broad market exposure cheaply elsewhere. Eric Balchunas argued that the manager’s fee needed to reflect how much the portfolio actually differed from that alternative.

The Bloomberg Intelligence analyst discussed the pressure on active managers during the November 13, 2024 Morning Show with JC Parets, Steve Strazza and Spencer Israel. He remained enthusiastic about ETFs, while seeing room for active strategies to attract investors as their pricing and portfolios changed.

A familiar portfolio needs a competitive price

Balchunas described managers lowering fees to account for the market exposure embedded in their funds. A portfolio built largely from familiar S&P 500 stocks could not easily justify an old-style active-management price simply by carrying an active label.

He said advisers were becoming more receptive as fees fell. In his view, they had not necessarily rejected active management itself. They objected to paying a premium for exposure they could obtain from a cheap index fund.

A portfolio that departed much further from the benchmark presented a different proposition. Balchunas considered the degree of difference relevant to evaluating the fee, rather than comparing every active strategy on price alone.

ETFs can carry active strategies too

The ETF format did not settle how a portfolio was managed. ETFs can follow an index or use an active investment strategy, as the SEC’s investor guidance explains.

Balchunas pointed to covered-call and defined-outcome strategies as examples of managers doing additional work within ETFs. He expected active management to find audiences through more competitive pricing and approaches that gave investors a different exposure or payoff structure.

He also viewed rules-based portfolios that tilted toward dividends or company fundamentals as evidence that investment selection remained important. Although those products could track indexes, he regarded the choice of rules as an investment decision.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-11-13 episode.

What pricing problem did Balchunas identify for active funds?

A portfolio containing many of the same stocks as a cheap index fund needed a fee that accounted for that overlap. He said advisers resisted paying a large premium for ordinary market exposure.

Link to this answer

Does being an ETF make a fund passive?

No. ETFs can be actively managed or track an index. Balchunas discussed active strategies operating within the ETF format.

Link to this answer

Did he think active management was disappearing?

No. He expected managers to find audiences by lowering fees and developing more distinct strategies, including approaches using options or specific portfolio-selection rules.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .