Takeaways
#- Parets saw a seasonal small-cap opportunity and tied his IWM view to holding above $170.
- Strazza wanted relative price confirmation before favoring small caps over established large-cap leaders.
- A possible short-term rebound did not settle the question of sustained outperformance.
- The hosts wanted the morning’s gaps and gains to hold through the session.
JC Parets was ready to give small caps a chance. Steve Strazza wanted more evidence. Both saw stocks rallying on November 14, 2023, but they disagreed about whether the move justified shifting toward the market’s smaller companies.
Their Morning Show debate separated two questions that can look similar on a strong day: whether small caps could rise, and whether they were becoming a better place to invest than the large companies already leading.
Parets favored the seasonal opportunity
Parets pointed to the tendency for smaller stocks to strengthen around the turn of the year. He argued that the effect could begin well before January and saw the current rally as consistent with that pattern.
His trade also had a price condition. Discussing the iShares Russell 2000 ETF, IWM, he said he could own it above $170, using the recent lows as a reference. He expected small caps to participate if the broader market continued rising into year-end.
That was a shorter-term opportunity in his argument. He pressed Strazza on whether small caps could outperform over the coming weeks, particularly if the S&P 500 reached new highs.
Strazza wanted the relative trend to change
Strazza kept returning to comparisons of small stocks with large ones, including IWM against the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, SPY. Those relative trends still favored the larger companies.
Seasonality and momentum divergences were useful observations, he said, but he wanted price confirmation before treating them as a change in leadership. Existing winners could also benefit as investors chased performance toward year-end.
He allowed that the deeply extended relative decline could produce a short-term rebound. For a more sustained allocation, he still preferred the stocks that were already working. He also rejected the suggestion that his caution meant he wanted to short small caps.
The opening rally still had to hold
Later, Patrick Dunuwila noted that small caps had lacked follow-through the previous week. The latest surge could improve that picture if it persisted.
The hosts also examined gaps higher in technology, semiconductors and homebuilders. Parets liked moves that cleared old resistance and stayed above it, giving him a level against which to judge the trade. Strazza cautioned that a large morning gain could fade and leave a very different chart by the close.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-11-14 episode.
Why did Parets favor small caps?
He saw a favorable seasonal period and expected small caps to participate in a broader rally. His IWM view was conditional on holding above $170.
Why was Strazza more cautious?
Comparisons of small stocks with large ones still favored the larger companies. He wanted a change in those relative price trends before treating small caps as sustained leaders.
What could undermine the morning’s bullish gaps?
A strong open could fade during the session. The hosts wanted stocks to hold above the resistance levels they had cleared, rather than give back the move by the close.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .