Takeaways
#- Sohn saw the appetite for money-market funds as evidence of investor caution, while recognizing the appeal of short-term yields around 5%.
- He did not require money-market outflows to confirm a stock rally; those assets had grown alongside equities in the 1990s.
- His historical rate study suggested that falling yields could help stocks even during a longer bond bear market, with clear hindsight and data limits.
- He used equal weighting to study participation and preferred selecting international country exposure, including Japan, over relying only on broad baskets.
Todd Sohn’s most striking observation was where investors were putting their money. On the November 7, 2023 Morning Show, he pointed to the large sums flowing into money-market funds while stocks were trying to recover.
The appeal was understandable: investors could earn around 5% in very short-term instruments without taking equity-market volatility. But to Sohn, the preference also revealed caution. He thought people remained scarred by the market and were comfortable leaving money in cash.
He saw the possibility that lower rates and a stronger stock market would eventually draw some of that money back toward equities. He also expected some to stay where it was, reflecting investors’ age, risk tolerance and need for stability.
Outflows were not a required signal
Asked whether money leaving money-market funds would confirm a shift back into stocks, Sohn resisted making that a requirement. He noted that money-market assets had risen alongside the stock market during the 1990s.
The flow data informed his view of investor psychology, but money-market balances did not have to fall for share prices to rise. Some money might return to stocks even while total money-market balances remained high or continued growing.
That distinction mattered to his interpretation of the current market. The enthusiasm for cash looked very different from the aggressive appetite he remembered in 2021. He thought a stronger equity market could revive investors’ fear of missing out, without assuming that everyone holding cash would become a stock buyer.
Falling yields could help without ending the larger rate cycle
Sohn had also examined mutual-fund performance during the long bond bear market from 1948 to 1980. He wanted to understand how equities had behaved during intervals when rates declined within that larger upward rate trend.
His table showed positive stock and fund performance during those pauses. He took that as a reason not to interpret every decline in Treasury yields as a warning that equities must fall. A move lower in yields could instead provide relief.
He was explicit about the limits of the exercise. Identifying the peaks and troughs was easier with hindsight, and he lacked enough historical detail to say precisely which stocks the old funds had owned. The comparison offered a possible path for stocks, rather than a detailed portfolio to copy.
The index was only one view of participation
Sohn thought the recent improvement in breadth was encouraging. More stocks were participating in the rebound, including some of the names that had been hit hardest. He saw that as a step toward better risk appetite, while acknowledging the possible role of short covering.
When the discussion turned to technology, he favored examining equal-weighted performance to see beyond the largest constituents. JC Parets argued for retaining the capitalization-weighted view as well. Sohn agreed that the choice depended on the question: an investor following a broad index and an analyst studying its internal participation needed different perspectives.
That concern with what a fund actually contained also shaped his international preferences. Japan stood out to him as a relatively balanced market with a strong chart. Rather than default to a broad international basket, he preferred considering individual countries.
He named the iShares MSCI Japan ETF, EWJ, and discussed pairing Japan with a Latin American market showing strength. Mexico’s EWW came up as an example. His approach was to select the country exposure deliberately, instead of accepting every market bundled into a regional or international allocation.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-11-07 episode.
Did Sohn expect all money held in cash to return to stocks?
No. He thought some could move back if yields fell or equities strengthened, but expected other investors to retain cash because of demographics and risk preferences. He also noted that money-market assets and stocks could rise together.
What was the limitation of his historical rate study?
He knew the rate peaks and troughs with hindsight and lacked detailed holdings data for the old mutual funds. The study helped him consider how stocks might respond to lower yields, without identifying an exact historical portfolio to reproduce.
Why did he prefer looking at individual countries?
He wanted to choose markets with stronger charts and a useful mix of constituents. Japan appealed to him, and he discussed EWJ alongside a possible Latin American country allocation, with Mexico’s EWW as an example.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .