Takeaways
#- Lundgren treated ARK’s sharp rebound as a move within a range until resistance around $50 gave way.
- He preferred considering the lower range or waiting for a breakout, rather than buying partway through a rebound simply because it felt safer.
- His quarterly trend table showed roughly 55% of the market in base categories, supporting his view that many stocks remained trendless.
- He could buy an extended leader in a bull market but would not initiate shorts in his most extended downside category.
David Lundgren did not need a rising market to follow a trend. A falling market could work, too. What troubled him on the November 8, 2023 Morning Show was the long stretch in which so many stocks were going nowhere.
The S&P 500’s recovery concealed that problem, he argued. A handful of large companies looked strong while the broader market remained stuck. For a trend follower, the distinction changed how to approach a rally, where to enter and when an apparently encouraging move might offer a worse trade.
The uncomfortable entry in ARK
Lundgren used the ARK Innovation ETF, ARKK, to explain the choice. The fund had rebounded sharply, but he still saw a trading range. He preferred steady progress within a trend to a record-breaking burst of volatility in a market that had been weak.
A move to the top of ARK’s range could nevertheless be substantial. He identified resistance around $50. If the fund broke through it, he saw the potential for a further move toward $80–$90.
There were two places he would consider the bullish argument: near the lower end of the range, when the decline made buying uncomfortable, or after a breakout above $50. What he wanted to avoid was waiting until a recovery above roughly $45 made the chart feel safer, then buying while the range still capped the move.
The emotional improvement could arrive before the technical improvement. Near the top of the range, a trader might feel more confident that a bottom was forming while giving up much of the room for a rebound.
Why the index did not settle the question
Lundgren contrasted the S&P 500 with the Value Line Geometric Index, which he used to examine broad participation. The major index’s retest of its 200-day average and former resistance looked constructive. His broader measure told a different story about the stocks available to buy.
His trend-stage table gave that distinction another form. He said roughly 55% of the market sat in one of four base categories on the quarterly timeframe. Those categories represented stocks moving sideways, whether the base followed an uptrend or a downtrend.
He also contrasted the share of market capitalization in a long-term uptrend with the share of individual stocks in that same category. The concentration of strength helped explain why the index and many investors’ watchlists looked so different.
Lundgren left open whether the divergence would resolve into a broader bull market. He recalled 1994 as an example of weak participation that eventually resolved upward. His point for the current trade was to choose an entry with a favorable setup rather than assume the eventual answer was already known.
Long and short trades needed different treatment
The environment had also changed his short positions. Lundgren said he had been short since July and had covered most of those trades, with a small amount remaining. He was adjusting as stocks returned toward the lower part of their ranges.
His breakout model classified stocks by how far they had extended from a pattern. In a strong bull market, he could initiate a long position even in the most extended category. Strong momentum could continue to identify leadership.
He did not apply that rule in reverse to heavily extended declines. He would not initiate a short in his most extended downside category. The sharp rebound in beaten-down stocks the previous week illustrated the danger of arriving late to that trade.
When the discussion returned to chart construction, Lundgren favored broad support and resistance zones over very precise lines. He wanted enough room for a trend to develop around areas that had mattered before, without allowing every small move through a single price to dictate the decision.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-11-08 episode.
Why did Lundgren distinguish buying ARK near its range low from buying above $45?
Near the lower range, a rebound offered more room before resistance. After a partial recovery above roughly $45, the chart might feel more comfortable while still sitting below the $50 area that capped the range. His alternative was to wait for a breakout above that resistance.
What did his base categories mean?
They described stocks moving sideways, either within a larger uptrend or after a downtrend. Lundgren said those four categories together accounted for roughly 55% of the market on his quarterly timeframe.
Why did he avoid shorting the most extended declines?
He treated the downside differently from upside momentum. A stock already stretched far below its pattern could rebound sharply, as beaten-down stocks had done the previous week. He would not initiate a short in that most extended category.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .