Takeaways
#- Wells Fargo rose in premarket trading despite a mixed report and an 11% year-over-year decline in net interest income.
- Strazza attributed part of the contrast with JPMorgan to the different expectations investors had for the two banks.
- He liked Wells Fargo’s chart position if the post-earnings move held.
- His planned Beat Report would compare earnings results with subsequent stock reactions to look for changes in expectations and trends.
Wells Fargo’s earnings report did not need to impress Steve Strazza for its stock to attract buyers. During The Morning Show on October 11, 2024, he and Spencer Israel watched shares rise roughly 3% to 3.5% in premarket trading after a quarter they described as mixed.
The bank had beaten the earnings-per-share estimate discussed on the show while coming up slightly short on revenue. Its net interest income fell 11% from a year earlier. Yet investors were bidding up the stock.
A lower bar can change the response
Strazza contrasted that reaction with JPMorgan’s more modest premarket gain. JPMorgan had produced the stronger net interest income performance, but he argued that investors already expected it to deliver. Wells Fargo faced a lower bar.
For Strazza, the useful information was the difference between the report and the price response. A company could post better numbers than a peer without producing the larger stock move if expectations were already higher.
Wells Fargo’s chart also mattered. The stock had spent months consolidating after its spring peak. Earnings could provide a catalyst to leave that range and eventually break the larger base. Strazza liked its position above the volume-weighted average price anchored to the May high, but his interest depended on the move holding.
Track the reaction across quarters
Later in the show, Strazza described a research project he expected to launch early the following year: the Beat Report. The plan was to classify earnings as beats, misses or mixed reports, then add a second observation: whether the stock rose afterward.
He wanted to compare those patterns across sectors and across growth and value stocks. Wells Fargo supplied an immediate example of why the extra step could matter. A mixed report and falling net interest income had still drawn a positive response.
Strazza was particularly interested in changes in those reactions. Stocks that began rising after disappointing results could be showing a shift in expectations as they formed a base. Conversely, a strong report followed by selling could suggest that enthusiasm was already reflected in the price. He hoped studying those changes would help identify potential trend reversals.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-10-11 episode.
Why did Strazza focus on Wells Fargo’s price response?
The bank’s mixed report still attracted buyers. He saw that response as evidence that expectations mattered alongside the reported results, particularly when comparing Wells Fargo with JPMorgan.
What did Strazza plan to track in the Beat Report?
He planned to classify earnings reports as beats, misses or mixed results and compare those categories with subsequent stock performance. He wanted to examine patterns by sector and across growth and value stocks.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .