Takeaways

#
  • Delwiche distinguished the number of stocks receiving upward and downward earnings revisions from an aggregate earnings estimate.
  • He saw a failed attempt to broaden participation, while Parets challenged an overly narrow description of which stocks had gained.
  • Delwiche preferred waiting in a generally long-only process to treating every weak market as an invitation to short.
  • His improvement checklist combined net new highs, stronger earnings revisions and slower increases in Baa corporate-bond yields.

Willie Delwiche was not buying the October dip. When JC Parets asked whether that meant shorting stocks would be easier, he rejected that choice too. His preference was to wait.

The October 23, 2023 Morning Show brought that neutral position into a debate about a market still struggling to produce broad participation. Parets emphasized the opportunity cost of sitting out a rally. Delwiche thought the cost of waiting in Treasury bills was relatively modest under the conditions he was seeing.

Earnings revisions were not all measuring the same thing

Parets began by asking about an earnings-revision trend he thought was still rising. Delwiche was seeing a rollover. Their first task was to establish what each measure represented.

Delwiche counted the stocks receiving upward and downward revisions, rather than relying on the aggregate earnings number. That distinction could explain why his reading differed from a headline estimate for the whole market.

After checking his data, he placed the peak around early September. Since the previous October’s index lows, the revision trend had generally made higher highs and higher lows. A routine pullback would not have concerned him in the same way. Over the latest week or two, however, he saw lower lows interrupting that pattern.

He regarded the change as one piece of evidence, made more concerning by the deterioration in market breadth. The two measures were weakening just as investors were looking for a strong fourth quarter.

A narrow advance was not the recovery he had expected

Parets challenged the idea that only a handful of stocks had risen, pointing to a substantial number of gains within the S&P 500. Delwiche’s concern was the market’s overall participation and its ability to sustain an advance.

He had seen the groundwork for a broader bull market earlier in the year. The balance of new highs and new lows had improved, reset and then attempted another expansion. In his assessment, that second attempt had failed to develop.

The discussion of microcaps made the disagreement more concrete. Parets did not dismiss their new lows, even though the companies were small by definition. Delwiche argued that the strongest market advances tended to involve more companies and more regions. A major index could rise with narrow leadership, but that was not the environment he preferred.

Nor did weak participation make a crash his central forecast. He thought prolonged, uneven sideways trading was a more likely outcome for the S&P 500. Investors accustomed to rapid recoveries could underestimate how long such a period might last.

Waiting carried an opportunity cost of its own

Parets pressed the alternative: earning interest in bills could look comfortable while technology stocks made a large move without the investor. Delwiche accepted that risk. He was making a judgment about the current balance of opportunity and downside, not claiming that cash always won.

His approach was generally long-only. When the equity evidence was unattractive, moving aside was a legitimate position. He did not need to replace every abandoned long idea with a short.

His relative-strength work was finding leadership in commodities, gold and Treasury bills. Gold’s resilience despite rising real yields interested him, although he distinguished the metal from mining shares. During acute market stress, he worried that the miners could behave more like equities than gold.

Three changes could bring him back toward stocks

Asked what would improve the outlook, Delwiche named three developments: more stocks making new highs than new lows, an upward turn in his earnings-revision measure, and a slower pace of rising interest rates.

For the last test, he specifically referenced 26-week momentum in Baa corporate-bond yields. Yields stabilizing or declining could give stocks another opening.

Steve Strazza also favored a market that remained difficult for longer, with opportunities in selected stocks and sectors instead of a broad assumption that everything should be bought. Delwiche would watch for the underlying evidence to improve before treating the next rebound as the durable advance he had been waiting for.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-10-23 episode.

Why did Delwiche and Parets describe earnings revisions differently?

Delwiche counted stocks with upward and downward revisions. He said that measure could differ from an aggregate earnings number and identified a rollover after an early-September peak.

Link to this answer

Was Delwiche expecting a market crash?

His central concern was a prolonged, uneven sideways period in the S&P 500. Weak breadth did not require him to predict a crisis or short stocks; he preferred to wait for better participation.

Link to this answer

What would have made him more constructive?

He wanted more new highs than new lows, improving earnings revisions and a slower rise in interest rates. He specifically mentioned 26-week momentum in Baa corporate-bond yields as part of the rate test.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .