Takeaways
#- Ro gave actual spending, hiring and business transactions more weight than statements of confidence or future intentions.
- Rising forward earnings estimates supported his view of business conditions, while Parets questioned their usefulness for timing stocks.
- Ro distinguished useful research inside a report from the strategist’s broader market recommendation.
- He acknowledged that market leadership could change and explained why index investing suited his approach to that uncertainty.
Sam Ro kept coming back to what people were doing with their money. Investors and consumers could tell survey takers that they felt terrible, but their purchases, hiring decisions and business orders offered another account of the economy.
That gap was central to his October 27, 2023 conversation with Spencer Israel and JC Parets. The hosts were watching a difficult stock market. Ro was reading economic and company data that looked considerably stronger than the mood around them.
Transactions carried more weight than intentions
Ro distinguished soft data, such as surveys about confidence or spending plans, from hard data tied to actual activity. Someone saying they intended to cut spending was different from a transaction record showing what they bought.
He acknowledged that surveys could offer leading information. But when describing the economy as it stood, he wanted to know whether businesses were hiring, consumers were purchasing goods and services, and companies were placing orders. He thought the persistent weakness in sentiment had obscured the strength in those measures.
That morning’s personal income and spending release gave the discussion a concrete reference. Ro pointed to consumer spending and employment as reasons the economy was still producing revenue for businesses. More people earning paychecks created more capacity to spend, even when their answers to confidence surveys remained gloomy.
An earnings forecast was a different kind of evidence
Ro also showed a chart of forward earnings estimates from research associated with Morgan Stanley strategist Mike Wilson. The estimates were rising, even though Wilson was widely associated with a bearish market view.
Ro separated the research from the strategist’s overall call. A report could contain useful company-level information even when a reader disagreed with its tactical conclusion. The chart drew on bottom-up earnings estimates, rather than requiring investors to accept every part of one strategist’s outlook.
Parets pushed back on its timing value. Earnings estimates had continued rising during part of the 2022 market decline and had kept falling after stocks began recovering. An improving forecast did not necessarily identify the market’s next turn.
Ro accepted that whether the estimates proved right remained to be seen. His point was that their direction fit other fundamental evidence he was seeing. He was using them to understand business conditions, while Parets was asking how well they helped time an investment.
Removing the biggest companies changed the question
The conversation turned to analyses that stripped major companies out of the stock market to show how weak everything else looked. Ro saw a use for examining components, but objected when a narrower measure was presented as the whole.
The largest technology businesses were connected to ordinary spending and business infrastructure. He cited services and products such as Alphabet’s YouTube, Microsoft’s Azure, Amazon’s AWS and Apple devices. Their size reflected substantial activity that could not simply be removed from an account of the economy.
That did not mean the same companies had to lead every future cycle. Israel asked whether investors should expect leadership to change. Ro allowed for new leaders while noting that older leaders could still appreciate. Losing first place and becoming a bad investment were different possibilities.
Ro’s own preference for index investing reduced the need to identify a permanent winner. As index membership changed, a holder could gain exposure to newer constituents without having to choose in advance which individual company would dominate indefinitely.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-10-27 episode.
What did Ro mean by hard and soft economic data?
He described surveys of confidence and intentions as soft data. Hard data captured activity such as purchases, hiring and business orders. He wanted to compare what people said with what their transactions showed.
Why did Parets challenge the earnings-estimate chart?
He noted that estimates had risen during part of the 2022 stock decline and fallen after the market started recovering. That history made him question their ability to identify a market turning point, even if they helped describe company fundamentals.
How did Ro approach the possibility of new market leaders?
He expected leadership to be capable of changing and preferred an index approach that could incorporate new constituents. He did not need to choose one company that would remain the leader indefinitely.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .