Takeaways
#- Antonelli cited 73% of S&P 500 constituents above their 200-day moving averages as evidence of broad participation.
- His equal-weight discretionary-to-staples ratio was near its highs but had not yet made a new cycle high.
- Defensive leadership needed to be measured relative to the market.
- Weaker breadth, deteriorating credit and tighter financial conditions were among the changes that could challenge his bullish view.
Michael Antonelli saw little evidence that investors were abandoning the bull market on the October 28, 2024 Morning Show. His case rested partly on how many stocks were participating: 73% of S&P 500 constituents were above their 200-day moving averages.
That reading sat within the roughly 60%–85% range shown on a Strategas chart he brought to the discussion. To Antonelli, it described the same broad uptrend that had persisted through much of the year. It also challenged the claim that only a handful of large technology stocks were carrying the market.
Equal weighting changed the consumer-sector comparison
Antonelli also followed equal-weight consumer discretionary stocks relative to equal-weight consumer staples. He used the ratio to assess whether investors favored businesses more sensitive to economic growth over defensive businesses.
Equal weighting reduced the influence of Amazon and Tesla on the discretionary side. JC Parets added that concentration mattered on the staples side too, where a few large companies carried substantial weight.
The ratio had recovered from its late-summer weakness and returned near its highs. It had not yet made a new cycle high. Antonelli considered that potential breakout an important next signal, rather than something the chart had already delivered.
What would change his view?
Parets asked Antonelli to consider the opposite outcome: what if the market had already peaked? Antonelli said he would look for the consumer-sector ratio to roll over and for defensive sectors to begin leading. The comparison needed to be relative to the broader market; a rising defensive stock alone would not establish that shift.
He also wanted to watch credit conditions, volatility and the dollar. Deteriorating credit, a VIX above 20 and tightening financial conditions would give him reasons to reassess. At the time, he did not see that combination developing.
After the interview, Parets returned to the breadth chart. A break below its established range would mean fewer S&P 500 stocks were sustaining intermediate-term uptrends. That would be a change from the pattern they had been observing all year, and a reason to pay closer attention even if the headline index still looked healthy.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-10-28 episode.
Why did Antonelli use an equal-weight consumer-sector ratio?
Equal weighting reduced the influence of the largest companies, including Amazon and Tesla in consumer discretionary. He used the ratio to compare appetite for economically sensitive businesses with demand for defensive businesses.
What would have made the breadth chart more concerning?
Parets said a break below its established range would show fewer S&P 500 stocks sustaining intermediate-term uptrends. That would mark a change from the broad participation they had observed during the year.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .