Takeaways
#- Sohn compared sector price trends with ETF flows to judge participation and enthusiasm; he did not use flows as a standalone trading signal.
- Rebalancing could require managers to buy long-duration bond funds as prices fell, complicating a bullish reading of TLT inflows.
- He thought cash yields around 5% made dividend-paying defensive stocks less compelling, particularly when those shares were also losing value.
- An equity rebound accompanied by further widening in credit spreads would concern him more than some widening during a stock-market decline.
Money was going into long-duration Treasury ETFs even as their prices fell. On the October 4, 2023 Morning Show, Spencer Israel wanted to know what an investor could actually do with that information. ETF strategist Todd Sohn offered a reason to pay attention and a reason to resist the obvious conclusion.
A manager with a target bond allocation could have to buy more after bonds declined. If new ETF shares were created to meet demand, the resulting inflow would not reveal whether buyers were restoring a bond allocation or betting that long-term rates were about to peak.
What flows added to the chart
Sohn liked the frequency of the data. ETF flows gave him a daily look at where money was entering and leaving funds. His next step was to compare those flows with the direction of the underlying sector.
Suppose a sector was rising while its ETFs attracted little new money. Sohn would consider the possibility that ETF investors had yet to become enthusiastic and the advance still had room to run. If substantial inflows arrived while the sector was already climbing, he would watch for the opposite: enthusiasm might be getting excessive. Neither observation was enough for him to make a trade.
He also watched trading volume. The iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT) was trading unusually heavily relative to its own history. To Sohn, that showed how much attention the bond selloff was commanding. Volume and net flows answered different questions: existing ETF shares can change hands without any new shares being created, as the Investment Company Institute explains.
Cash had become a competitor for defensive stocks
JC Parets had come into the interview puzzled by consumer staples. If investors were worried about stocks, why weren’t they buying businesses traditionally regarded as defensive? He wondered whether the lack of relative strength meant there was less risk aversion than the headlines suggested.
Sohn approached the question through the alternatives available to someone seeking income. When cash paid very little, an investor might buy a dividend-paying stock for its yield and comparatively quiet price behavior. In October 2023, Sohn said, cash could yield about 5%, while staples shares were falling and businesses faced pressure from higher operating costs.
That changed the competition. An investor could want safety and income without putting money into utilities, real estate or packaged-food companies. Sohn therefore treated the weakness in staples primarily as an interest-rate story.
Where he looked for a clearer warning
Credit spreads had widened somewhat as stocks fell. Sohn found that less troubling than a divergence in which stocks bounced and spreads continued to widen. If equity investors were buying a recovery while credit investors kept demanding more compensation for risk, he would pay closer attention.
He viewed the equity selloff as an ugly correction, with pockets of strength in communications, technology and energy. The performance of the largest stocks could conceal weaker companies within the same sector, so a sector’s ranking did not settle the question of participation.
Asked to choose one sector for the fourth quarter, he chose energy. He liked the bases forming in integrated oil stocks, while acknowledging that the move in crude itself might be losing steam. The stocks had spent months building those patterns; he was still waiting for them to break out.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-10-04 episode.
Why might a falling bond ETF attract inflows?
Sohn said managers with a target allocation could need to add bonds after a decline. Net inflows do not reveal whether buyers were restoring an allocation or making a discretionary bet on a bottom.
What did he look for when sector prices and flows differed?
A rising sector with modest inflows could still have room for more participation. Large inflows during an existing advance made him more alert to excessive enthusiasm. He considered both alongside other evidence.
Why didn’t Sohn take weak consumer staples as a simple vote of confidence in stocks?
He thought cash yielding about 5% competed directly with the dividend and safety investors had previously sought in staples. Weakness in those shares could reflect that competition even if investors remained cautious.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .