Takeaways
#- A momentum label did not imply a fixed technology or high-growth allocation; the holdings could change with market leadership.
- Sohn preferred QMOM’s attention to the persistence of gains, while Parets questioned that choice through a longer performance comparison.
- The relative performance of the two funds differed with the starting point the hosts used.
- Sohn distinguished high-beta selection from momentum and urged attention to the industry exposure behind a factor comparison.
A momentum fund holding Coca-Cola and Walmart surprised Steve Strazza. He had expected a different mix of stocks when looking for a momentum allocation. The discussion on the October 7, 2024 Morning Show gave Todd Sohn an opening to explain why funds sharing that label could still behave differently.
The path of the gains mattered to Sohn
The hosts were looking at the iShares MSCI USA Momentum Factor ETF, MTUM. They discussed how its sector mix could change as different groups gained strength. Consumer staples could appear in a momentum portfolio, just as energy or technology could dominate at another point.
Sohn preferred the approach used by Alpha Architect’s U.S. Quantitative Momentum ETF, QMOM. In his description, the selection process considered the persistence and consistency of price gains as well as the return itself. He contrasted a stock that jumped sharply in one event with one that kept advancing over time.
That construction was closer to what Sohn wanted from a momentum strategy. His preference concerned how the fund selected stocks; it did not establish that it had delivered the best result over every period.
Parets changed the comparison window
JC Parets challenged Sohn by looking back to the prior speculative peak in early 2021. On the charts they examined, MTUM had made more progress from that starting point, while QMOM looked stronger over a shorter interval.
Sohn acknowledged that the products would perform differently and maintained his preference for QMOM’s design. The exchange separated the appeal of a selection rule from the return produced over a chosen period. A shorter window could favor the fund he liked without resolving the longer comparison Parets raised.
High beta raised a different holdings question
Parets also asked whether the Invesco S&P 500 High Beta ETF, SPHB, offered a similar exposure. Sohn distinguished its beta-based selection from a momentum strategy. He warned that the high-beta portfolio could have a substantial semiconductor concentration.
That mattered when interpreting a high-beta-versus-low-beta chart. Weakness in the former could reflect semiconductors lagging utilities or staples. Sohn wanted the hosts to examine those underlying industry exposures before attributing the entire move to a broad change in risk appetite.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-10-07 episode.
What did Sohn prefer about QMOM?
He favored a process that considered the consistency of price gains as well as their size, rather than treating a large one-time jump as equivalent to a persistent advance.
Why did Parets question that preference?
He compared the funds from the early 2021 speculative peak and found a different picture from the shorter-term comparison. Sohn’s preferred design did not lead over every period they examined.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .