Takeaways
#- Hirsch interpreted strength during August and September's normally weak seasonal window as evidence supporting the ongoing advance.
- His fourth-quarter S&P 500 target was 7,100, while his midterm-cycle concerns were concentrated in a different period during 2026.
- He said the small-cap January effect could begin turning in late October, with much of the tendency concentrated in late December.
- The speakers used deviations from seasonal expectations as information and acknowledged that historical cycles could fail.
Jeff Hirsch arrived at the October 8, 2025 Morning Show with a bullish year-end outlook. His reasoning began with a decline that had failed to materialize. Stocks had advanced through August and September, a stretch he and JC Parets normally treated as a difficult part of the seasonal calendar.
To Hirsch, that failure of bearish seasonality supplied information about the strength of the market. A historical tendency was useful partly because it established an expectation. When prices behaved differently, he wanted to understand what that deviation implied.
Strong prices mattered more than a weak calendar
Parets opened the discussion by comparing gains across U.S. indexes and international markets during August and September. Strength was visible beyond the largest American companies, making it harder to dismiss the advance as a narrow exception.
Hirsch interpreted those results as evidence that forces supporting stocks were more powerful than the seasonal headwind. He applied the same logic in reverse: if a market failed to rally during a normally favorable period, that would be a warning.
He said his seasonal MACD signal had turned positive and that he was finding few bearish indications in his research. His outlook called for a strong fourth quarter, with 7,100 on the S&P 500 as a target. That was his forecast at the time of the broadcast, supported by the price behavior he was observing.
The calendar did not require investors to wait for a textbook October correction. Parets noted that the market had already been advancing instead of offering the weakness that sometimes preceded the favorable November-through-January window. Hirsch was willing to act on that strength.
The bullish year-end view had a different horizon from the midterm warning
Their enthusiasm for the remainder of 2025 did not extend unchanged through the following year. Hirsch discussed a weaker historical stretch in the second and third quarters of midterm election years. In the four-year cycle he was studying, the more favorable window followed later, from the fourth quarter of the midterm year into the second quarter of the pre-election year.
That gave him a reason to revisit risk as the calendar turned. He could favor the ongoing rally and still expect a more difficult environment during 2026.
Parets added another timing consideration. A breadth thrust from May had supported his view of a durable advance, and its approximate one-year horizon would reach the same part of 2026 that concerned Hirsch. The two observations lined up, but Parets questioned whether the fit looked too convenient.
Hirsch agreed that the cycle would eventually fail. Their discussion treated the overlap as something to monitor, with changing prices still capable of challenging the seasonal expectation.
The January effect began before January
Small caps supplied a more immediate example of why a seasonal label could be misleading. Hirsch described the January effect as the tendency for small stocks to outperform large stocks around that part of the year, but said the turn often began in late October. Much of the effect, in his research, had shifted into the final two weeks of December.
He connected that timing to the end of tax-loss selling and year-end flows, including bonuses. Waiting until January to start watching the relationship could miss the period he considered relevant.
Small caps were already strengthening during this discussion. Hirsch also associated sustained small-cap leadership with later stages of a bull market, which made it compatible with both his immediate optimism and his concern about the following year. It was not an automatic instruction to become bearish as soon as smaller companies improved.
Different holdings could be at different points in the calendar
Hirsch's sector comments showed that the broad forecast did not dictate the same action everywhere. He said he retained gold exposure through GLD after selling mining positions. He also discussed Bitcoin's fourth-quarter tendency and identified IBIT as the ETF he personally used.
Utilities presented a different seasonal question. He acknowledged the enthusiasm around electricity demand and data centers, while saying that the favorable seasonal period he had been following was running its course.
For Parets, the most useful part of the conversation was the gap between expected and actual behavior. A seasonal pattern gave him a reference, and the market's refusal to follow it could become the signal. In October 2025, that refusal had strengthened their bullish outlook, while leaving a separate set of questions for the next calendar year.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2025-10-08 episode.
Why did Hirsch find August and September's strength encouraging?
Those months normally presented a seasonal headwind in his framework. Their strength suggested that other forces supporting stocks were outweighing that tendency, which reinforced his fourth-quarter outlook.
When did he expect the January effect to begin?
He said small-cap relative performance could start turning in late October, with much of the effect concentrated in the final two weeks of December rather than waiting until January.
How did his 2026 concerns fit with the bullish outlook?
They concerned different horizons. Hirsch favored the remainder of 2025 but was watching the historically weaker second and third quarters of midterm election years as a reason to reassess risk in 2026.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .