Takeaways

#
  • Stockton wanted the S&P 500 to defend its recent breakout area through the next close.
  • She regarded a potential TLT rebound as countertrend while longer-term yield momentum remained positive.
  • Small-cap weakness and mega-cap resilience gave different readings of market breadth.
  • Energy, natural gas and gold required separate time horizons and conditions.
  • Perz would use the long end of the curve after the hike to assess inflation persistence versus slowing growth.
Chapters
  1. Why the reaction is harder than the Fed forecast
  2. The recovery level Parets wanted in TLT
  3. Stockton assesses support and breadth
  4. A Treasury bounce versus the larger trend
  5. Gold and sector leadership across horizons
  6. Perz lays out two long-yield scenarios

JC Parets wanted to buy bonds. Katie Stockton could see why the trade was tempting, but she wanted him to be precise about what he would be buying: a possible countertrend move against a larger trend that still favored rising yields.

That distinction anchored the September 16 Morning Show. The Fed announcement was still ahead, and the panel expected a rate increase. Rather than treating the announcement as the answer, Stockton, Parets and Jason Perz described the price behavior they would need to see after it.

Steve Strazza made the initial problem clear. A trader trying to predict the event had to get both the decision and the market's reaction right, then contend with the reaction to that reaction. Watching the market absorb the news was an available alternative.

The stock market had support to defend

Stockton saw room for a favorable short-term response because the S&P 500 was oversold and near the breakout area she identified around 7,618. She wanted to see whether that support survived the following day's close.

A failure there would increase her concern about the fourth quarter. Rising crude prices, yields, credit spreads and volatility were all parts of her broader risk assessment. The major indexes had remained resilient, but that resilience needed to persist through the event.

Breadth required a similar distinction between horizons. Many stocks remained above their 200-day averages while fewer were above their 20-day averages. Stockton interpreted the shorter-term weakness as potentially temporary within an intact primary bull trend, while watching for evidence that the weakness was spreading.

She was more concerned about small caps, where she identified a short-term breakdown in IWM and weaker relative performance against the S&P 500. Mega-cap technology could support the headline indexes even when the equal-weight experience felt considerably less healthy.

TLT needed more than a buy signal

Parets was explicit that he did not yet own TLT. Earlier in the show, he described a recovery above roughly $83 as the condition that would interest him.

Stockton explained why she wanted confirmation. TLT and related Treasury proxies had recently flashed DeMark buy signals, but the signals had failed to generate the anticipated move. Strong momentum could overwhelm a countertrend signal.

She had seen a confirmed breakout in the 10-year yield above the area around 4.74%, putting 5% in view. Monthly momentum also supported the upward yield trend. A pause near a psychologically important number was plausible; a durable reversal was a bigger claim.

"So I think you could buy bonds for a counter trend move once you have a little bit more evidence, right?" she said.

She also separated absolute returns from relative performance. Bonds might outperform stocks during an equity correction even if their own long-term trend remained difficult. A volatility or credit-spread breakout would help identify that environment.

Energy and gold had their own clocks

The bond question mattered to Parets because he held energy exposure. Stockton saw the possibility of a short-term crude pullback and discussed reducing energy exposure temporarily, rather than treating it as the end of the larger trend.

Natural gas offered another setup. She found its improving momentum intriguing and pointed to Range Resources, RRC, as an example of a stock with a steadier long-term trend. Parets disclosed that natural gas was the one contrarian idea among bonds, Nike and gas that he had actually acted on.

Gold also depended on the horizon. Stockton described a secular uptrend but a loss of monthly momentum that could produce a long trading range. A constructive short-term view therefore did not necessarily mean she saw a lasting entry for the following year.

She remained constructive on technology leadership when the tape was strong. A confirmed correction, however, would lead her to consider traditional defensive groups rather than assume the same leaders would work in every environment.

Perz wanted the market's answer

Jason Perz arrived with a different bond position. He preferred the short side over a longer horizon, while allowing that someone else could trade a bounce.

"I mean, it depends on the time frame, right?" he said.

He laid out two possible responses to a hike. If the 30-year yield continued rising, he would read that as evidence the market did not think the increase had restrained inflation. If long yields moved lower, he would consider whether the market was signaling a slowing growth and inflation cycle, with more defensive positioning potentially warranted.

That framework did not require him to abandon energy merely because the first rate hike occurred. He wanted the behavior of the long end of the curve to tell him whether the environment had changed.

Parets had a recovery level, Stockton had support and momentum conditions, and Perz had two intermarket scenarios.

Questions and answers

#

From the September 16, 2026 conversation.

Why did Katie Stockton call a possible bond rally a countertrend move?

The larger yield trend remained upward, and recent Treasury buy signals had failed to produce the expected recovery. Stockton wanted more evidence before acting on another signal. A pause or bounce could occur without reversing the primary bond trend.

Link to this answer

What did Jason Perz want the long end of the curve to reveal after the Fed decision?

Continued gains in the 30-year yield would suggest that inflation pressure had not been restrained in his framework. Falling long yields could point toward slowing growth and inflation. He wanted that market response before deciding whether the environment supporting his positions had changed.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .