Takeaways

#
  • Tharp reported buying TLT puts below $97. Another put depended on whether the $92–$92.50 zone broke.
  • He favored buying calls or puts when potential movement justified the premium at risk and traded less when markets were quiet.
  • A short-term Russell topping pattern and a longer sideways range could describe the same prices. Tharp wanted more damage before turning broadly bearish.
  • Tharp saw possible resistance in crude near $94–$95 while continuing to watch energy stocks for long trades.

Christian Tharp had already made one bearish trade in long-term Treasuries. When the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT) fell below $97, he and his team bought puts. By the September 18, 2023 Morning Show, the fund was near another area he had marked, $92 to $92.50. This time, he told JC Parets, he was still sitting on his hands.

The hosts had been debating what the market for federal funds futures said about the Fed’s next move. Tharp seldom thought about those contracts in his day-to-day trading. The price of TLT gave him a more direct way to decide whether to act: if buyers defended that band, there was no breakdown to trade. If the band gave way, he would probably buy a put again. Other traders he worked with might use a credit spread or a diagonal. His own earlier trade was the simpler one.

Why a quiet market meant fewer trades

For a trader who usually bought calls or puts, getting the direction right was only part of the job. Tharp liked movement. He was willing to risk the premium on an option when the underlying security could move far enough to make the potential gain several times what he had put at risk. A quieter market made that harder, and he tended to trade less.

Traders could use candlesticks, Bollinger Bands or point-and-figure charts to find an entry. Tharp compared that choice to picking the horse that got you to the starting gate. Once the race started, what mattered to him was how much the position could earn relative to what he stood to lose.

How much of a rally was there to reverse?

Tharp was willing to sell weakness in bonds without becoming bearish on stocks as a whole. The hosts put up a Russell chart with what looked, on a short enough time frame, like a head-and-shoulders top. There had been an advance from the March low, so there was something for a sharp pullback to reverse. Zoom out, Parets argued, and much of the same price action looked like a sideways range. Calling it a major top required a much bigger uptrend to have run its course.

Tharp could see how someone starting from the previous October low might think a rally had topped. He still wanted to see more damage. The broader market had advanced from roughly 3,800 to 4,600 earlier in the year; a few weeks of weakness at a seasonally soft time struck him as an ordinary pullback.

In crude oil, it was the upper edge of a channel that caught his eye. On his chart of the past couple of years, $94 to $95 was an area where the advance might run into trouble. He was watching energy stocks from the long side even as he marked possible resistance in the commodity.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-09-18 episode.

What would have triggered Tharp’s next TLT trade?

He wanted the fund to break down through the $92 to $92.50 support area. If it did, his likely trade was a put, as it had been when the fund broke below $97.

Link to this answer

Why did a quieter market change how often he traded?

Tharp usually paid a premium to own calls or puts. He wanted the underlying price to move enough to offer a worthwhile gain relative to that outlay; he found fewer opportunities when movement slowed.

Link to this answer

Why wasn’t the Russell pattern enough for a broad bearish call?

A short-term rally could be reversing while the larger index remained in a range. Tharp thought a pullback after the earlier advance was consistent with the season and wanted more price deterioration before changing his outlook.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .