Takeaways

#
  • Roque saw strength in oil and several agricultural contracts, but weak industrial metals and a sideways gold price held him back from calling it a broad commodity bull market.
  • Parets emphasized gold’s strength in other currencies. Roque acknowledged those returns while waiting for the U.S.-dollar chart to clear resistance.
  • Over 34 Nasdaq trading sessions, Roque counted 31 with more new lows than new highs, and 31 with more than 100 new lows.
  • He saw deteriorating weekly momentum in semiconductors and regarded energy as the strongest equity sector, without assuming it was immune to a market correction.

JC Parets had been looking forward to showing John Roque his chart of stocks against commodities. On September 19, 2023, he thought the lower highs in that ratio put commodities in the fourth year of a long advance relative to equities. Crude was at its highest level of the year. Cattle and orange juice had made records. Roque, the head of technical strategy at 22V Research, didn't dispute which markets had worked. He wanted to know why copper and gold weren't doing more.

Oil could lead a commodity advance, Roque said. Cattle, sugar and orange juice could join in, too. But industrial metals were generally weak. Gold didn't have to lead a broad commodity bull market, he told Parets; in the ones he had studied, it had at least participated. Without that confirmation, he was reluctant to call strength in selected contracts a bull market across the group.

Gold had visited $2,000 before

It wasn't a question of whether Roque could imagine gold rising. He recalled writing a bullish note in October 2001, when the metal was around $280 an ounce. Back then, investors he spoke with could see gold holding up better than expensive stocks, but few expected it to rise on its own. In 2023 he again saw little enthusiasm. What he no longer saw was a fresh breakout in dollars.

The price had spent several years going sideways, with repeated visits to the area around $2,000. Parets noted that gold had already passed its 2011 highs in several other currencies. Roque agreed those returns were real for someone investing in rupees or euros. They still left a U.S. investor looking at resistance on the dollar chart. Skepticism might help sustain a breakout once it happened; it couldn't make the price go through that level.

Weakness beneath the Nasdaq

Roque also questioned how much comfort to take from the biggest technology stocks. In 31 of the preceding 34 trading sessions, he counted more Nasdaq stocks making new lows than new highs. He separately counted 31 sessions with more than 100 new lows. He dated the corrective phase to mid-July. An occasional headline about a winning stock told him little about the environment in which the rest had to trade.

For the chip companies, he put the PHLX Semiconductor Sector Index beside the stories about demand. Texas Instruments and ASML had weakened. The index had slipped below a 10-week moving average that had already crested, and its weekly momentum indicator had turned down. Roque wanted to see the sector become oversold and that momentum turn back up before he expected a better entry. He saw downside risk to $150 in Apple, without needing to predict a collapse in the stock market to entertain a correction.

Energy remained the strongest equity sector on his screen. If other stocks weakened further, investors might crowd into the one group that was still working. Or the weakness could reach energy as well. Roque liked the stocks; he just didn't think their strength settled what would happen to the rest of the market.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-09-19 episode.

Why did Roque care about gold if oil was already rising?

In the broad commodity bull markets he remembered, gold had participated even when it wasn't the leader. Its repeated approaches to $2,000 and weakness in industrial metals left him looking for wider confirmation.

Link to this answer

Did gold’s gains in euros or rupees count?

Yes, Roque said. Those gains mattered to investors using those currencies. They did not remove the resistance a dollar investor still saw.

Link to this answer

Which semiconductor signals would Roque want to improve?

The sector index was below its rolling-over 10-week average and its weekly momentum had weakened. He wanted an oversold condition followed by a turn higher in the weekly momentum measure.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .