Takeaways

#
  • Koyfman checked the high-yield spread because it measures the premium risky corporations pay relative to government debt, even when borrowing costs are rising for both.
  • High-yield spreads had widened ahead of the 2008 crisis. In September 2023 he saw a previous spike followed by a return to tight spreads.
  • The two-year Treasury yield had recovered from the regional banking scare, unlike the early pricing of rate cuts in 2007.
  • Parets cited Aon as a stock making highs with buy recommendations from just two of its 19 covering firms.

Stocks had rallied in 2007, too. It was the part of the bearish argument Rob Koyfman found easiest to understand when he joined JC Parets and Steve Strazza on September 21, 2023. Investors had just watched the Federal Reserve raise rates at a pace that made him wonder how much strain the economy could take. Stock prices alone couldn't settle the question. What interested him was whether lenders were already demanding more money to take corporate risk.

Parets asked him to show exactly what he meant by a deteriorating credit market. Koyfman opened the corporate credit dashboard on Koyfin and pulled up the spread between high-yield corporate debt and Treasuries. When risky borrowers have to pay more relative to the government, the spread widens. A rise in Treasury yields can make borrowing more expensive across the board without necessarily producing that widening.

What lenders charged before the crisis

In Koyfman’s comparison, the trouble in credit was visible while stocks were still doing well in 2007. Lenders had started to demand more compensation for owning the riskier bonds. That made the stock market’s strength look much less reassuring than it would have in isolation.

The September 2023 chart showed a different sequence. Spreads had spiked earlier, then settled back down. Koyfman put the latest reading near the tightest levels since 2022. It was quite possible for them to widen again. But if corporate borrowers were already running into the kind of trouble implied by the 2007 comparison, he would have expected some sign of it in the premium paid by the least creditworthy issuers. The high-yield spread series published by the St. Louis Fed illustrates the distinction between that premium and the level of rates.

What the two-year yield had done since the bank failures

Koyfman next turned to the short end of the Treasury market. In 2007, it had begun anticipating Fed rate cuts well before the worst of the financial crisis. The two-year Treasury yield in 2023 had touched a level familiar from that earlier period. The direction from which it got there mattered to him more than the coincidence of the number.

Earlier in 2023, traders had marked down the expected path of rates as Silicon Valley Bank and other regional banks came under pressure. By the September broadcast, the two-year yield was back near its highs. Koyfman wasn't prepared to read an imminent crisis into a rates market that had just moved the other way.

The distinction between what people said and what a market priced also came up in their discussion of Aon (AON). Parets said the stock kept making highs, yet just two of the 19 firms covering it had a buy recommendation. Koyfman liked to check three separate numbers: the average recommendation, the distance between the average price target and the stock, and how many analysts covered it in the first place. Nineteen firms mostly declining to call a rising stock a buy told him something quite different from one analyst barely following a company.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-09-21 episode.

Why did Koyfman look at high-yield spreads instead of just Treasury yields?

A Treasury yield reflects the government's cost of borrowing. The spread showed him how much extra investors demanded for riskier corporate bonds and whether that premium was increasing.

Link to this answer

What did he see in the two-year Treasury after Silicon Valley Bank failed?

Rate expectations had fallen amid the bank stress earlier in 2023. By September the two-year yield was near its highs again, a different path from the advance pricing of Fed cuts in 2007.

Link to this answer

What stood out about Wall Street’s recommendations on Aon?

Parets counted 19 firms following it and only two recommending a buy, even as it made highs. The size of the analyst group mattered: the gap between price and sentiment wasn't simply the product of a stock receiving very little coverage.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .