Takeaways
#- Tolle’s favorable personal view of India did not override the index’s inclusion rules.
- Country weights used scores covering personal and economic freedom.
- Within eligible countries, the method selected large, liquid stocks and excluded state-owned enterprises.
- Market size and liquidity requirements could exclude a country before the freedom-weighting step.
Perth Tolle was bullish on India. That did not put it into her fund. On the September 23, 2024 Morning Show, she explained why the Freedom 100 Emerging Markets ETF followed its index rules even when she liked an excluded market.
Tolle joined Spencer Israel, JC Parets and Steve Strazza to discuss how FRDM selected and weighted its holdings.
Country weights came before stock weights
Tolle said the country allocations used third-party scores covering both personal and economic freedom. Economic freedom addressed the market and business environment; personal freedom included matters such as speech, expression and protection from coercion.
The composite country score supplied the main input to the country-weighting process. Within each represented country, she described selecting ten large, liquid stocks and excluding state-owned enterprises. Those stocks were then weighted by market capitalization within the country’s allocation.
That distinction mattered when Strazza asked whether a large Taiwan position was an active bet on AI. Tolle said the country weights came from the methodology. Taiwan’s weight also reflected market movement after the annual rebalance.
India had to meet the same threshold
Tolle described India as the most borderline country in the methodology. A score above the average qualified a country for inclusion; a score below it did not. India had fallen out of the index a few years earlier, despite her favorable personal view.
She said the portfolio was reassessed annually, with the next rebalance scheduled for January. She hoped India would qualify again, but her preference could not override the rules.
Freedom alone was not enough for inclusion
There was also a market-access filter. Tolle said the starting country universe matched MSCI’s emerging-markets universe at the time, but minimum market-capitalization and liquidity requirements narrowed the eligible set before the freedom weighting.
She gave Peru as an example of a market that was large enough but insufficiently liquid for the methodology. Some relatively free countries therefore remained outside the portfolio. The fund needed holdings that it could trade, as well as countries that qualified under its freedom criteria.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-09-23 episode.
Why was India excluded despite Tolle’s bullish view?
She said India’s score had fallen below the methodology’s inclusion threshold. Her personal opinion could not override the rules, although she hoped it would qualify at a future rebalance.
Were FRDM’s stocks weighted only by freedom scores?
No. Tolle described freedom-based country allocations, then market-capitalization weighting of selected stocks within those allocations.
Could a relatively free country still be left out?
Yes. Tolle said countries first had to meet market-capitalization and liquidity requirements. She cited Peru as large enough but insufficiently liquid for the methodology.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .