Takeaways
#- Colombia, Poland, Chile, the Czech Republic and Brazil were the five cheapest markets in Faber’s developed- and emerging-market comparison that September.
- Faber favored inexpensive, cash-generating businesses and liked to see an improving price trend. Country rankings alone did not supply that trend.
- Cambria’s valuation approach gave technology a small weight in its U.S. shareholder-yield portfolio and the largest sector weight in its emerging-market counterpart at the time.
- For an adviser, losses in an unfamiliar country could be harder to explain to a client than losses in familiar U.S. shares.
When Meb Faber told an audience in Bogotá that Colombian stocks were expensive, the reception was chilly. Local investors explained to him that pension contributions kept flowing into equities and oil was fetching a high price. Years later, on the September 29, 2023 Morning Show, Faber had different news for them. Colombia now ranked first on his list of cheap markets, and he rather hoped they would invite him back.
The price-to-earnings measure he cited was around eight. Faber used a long-term measure called CAPE, which compares price with earnings averaged over a decade and adjusted for inflation. On his developed- and emerging-market list, Poland ranked second, followed by Chile, the Czech Republic and Brazil. None had to be in an uptrend to make that list. That was a separate question, and the one Steve Strazza particularly wanted to answer.
Two reasons a market could make the cut
Cambria’s approach drew on both value and trend. Faber’s preferred combination was an inexpensive investment whose price had already started rising. If investors still disliked it, so much the better. A stock market could be cheap because a political crisis, commodity bust or deteriorating economy had driven its price down. The multiple alone couldn’t distinguish a recovery from another leg lower.
Strazza asked whether choosing value over growth, foreign over U.S. and small over large really amounted to the same trade. Faber saw overlap, but his own funds showed the limits of that explanation. Technology accounted for only about 5% of the U.S. shareholder-yield portfolio he described. In its emerging-market counterpart, technology was the largest sector on the valuation criteria they used. Applying a similar screen to different markets turned up quite different businesses.
The U.S. example was the Cambria Shareholder Yield ETF (SYLD), then ten years old. Faber described it as a long-only portfolio combining value with some quantitative momentum. He looked for businesses returning cash through buybacks or dividends at low valuations. An expensive U.S. benchmark didn’t mean he had to leave the country to find a reasonably priced company.
What the last ten years could tell him
Faber showed rolling ten-year U.S. stock returns to illustrate just how persuasive the recent American record could look. His chart also had earlier peaks around the Roaring Twenties, the Nifty Fifty era and the internet bubble. What followed each peak was different. He couldn’t tell the hosts what would follow the pandemic-era enthusiasm, but he saw little reason to assume the preceding decade’s returns would repeat.
That was also the point of his earlier research, The Case for Global Investing. Investors could compare what a dollar of historical earnings cost across markets without predicting when U.S. leadership would end. In the interview, Faber said he wanted quality businesses generating cash and suggested that traders could look for a moving-average signal or a breakout as evidence of improving demand.
He had another explanation for why the cheapest column stayed unpopular: the career risk of owning it. An adviser who bought an out-of-favor market and did well might get a pat on the back. If the same investment lost money, the client might want to know why the adviser had ventured into the Czech Republic in the first place. Faber’s country rankings directed his attention precisely toward the markets that were hardest to defend in that conversation.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-09-29 episode.
Why was Colombia back on Faber’s radar?
Its shares had fallen far enough for the market to move from expensive to the cheapest in his comparison. He put its earnings multiple around eight, and still separated that valuation from any evidence of an uptrend.
How did his U.S. fund look for value?
Faber described SYLD as a long-only fund looking for companies at attractive valuations that returned cash to shareholders, with a quantitative momentum component. He cited both share buybacks and dividends.
What did Faber mean by career risk in a cheap market?
An adviser could have trouble explaining an unsuccessful investment in an unpopular country to clients accustomed to familiar U.S. stocks. Faber saw that reluctance as one reason cheap markets could stay neglected.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .