Takeaways

#
  • Metallurgical coal and thermal coal serve different end markets and had different drivers in Warder’s analysis.
  • Warrior Met’s cost position helped explain its relative strength in his view.
  • Warder preferred waiting for tactical pullbacks as restocking season matured.
  • He distinguished core holdings in diversified coal producers from more tactical positions in pure metallurgical names.
  • Fuel competition and input costs linked coal with the broader commodity outlook.
Chapters
  1. Natural gas and bonds as separate trades
  2. Snowflake and the software earnings debate
  3. Kenny Glick’s VWAP retest framework
  4. Matt Warder explains the two coal markets
  5. Warrior Met, producer margins and seasonal timing
  6. Fuel competition and the broader commodity cycle

The coal stocks on the September 3, 2026 Morning Show did not all represent the same trade. Matt Warder distinguished coal used in steelmaking from coal burned to generate electricity, then explained why both markets had strengthened for different reasons. Warrior Met Coal's chart attracted the hosts' attention, but Warder's enthusiasm for the industry came with a tactical caution: restocking season was approaching its later stages, and he preferred opportunities on pullbacks.

That distinction between an attractive theme and an attractive entry echoed the show's earlier debate about natural gas and bonds. JC Parets and Steve Strazza were willing to explore unpopular trades, while remaining specific about the instrument, time horizon and confirmation they wanted.

Start with what the coal is used for

Warder explained that thermal coal feeds power generation. Its quality and value depend partly on heat content and impurities. Metallurgical coal is used to make coke for steel production, tying its demand to a different industrial process.

The distinction changed how he interpreted the rally. On the metallurgical side, Warder attributed stronger prices partly to disrupted Chinese production and replacement buying in the seaborne market. He also watched India, which he believed had delayed restocking and might still need to purchase material.

His thermal-coal thesis depended more on electricity demand and competition with natural gas. To compare fuels, he reduced their delivered prices to a common unit of energy. Higher gas costs could make coal more competitive where switching was possible, creating a connection that a simple comparison of stock charts would miss.

Those were Warder's explanations for the conditions at the time of the broadcast. Their durability depended on supply, inventories and demand continuing to develop as he expected.

Why Warrior Met looked different

Parets highlighted HCC, Warrior Met Coal, as it approached new highs. Warder described the company as an export-focused metallurgical producer with a favorable cost position. In his view, margins helped explain why its stock looked stronger than some peers.

He contrasted it with Alpha Metallurgical Resources and Ramaco Resources. Higher costs and short positioning could produce a different response to changing coal prices. A weaker-looking chart was not necessarily a comfortable short: a commodity rebound could create a sharp move in a smaller, heavily shorted producer.

The companies therefore offered different exposure even within the same coal category. Cost structure affected how much of a commodity-price improvement could reach earnings. Positioning and liquidity could affect the path of the stock. Warder warned against treating all three as interchangeable expressions of one bullish view.

Seasonality shaped the next decision

Warder remained constructive over a longer horizon but wanted tactical traders to respect the stage of the cycle. "I think you want to wait out this part of the cycle," he said. He described using volatility-based bands to look for entries nearer the lower part of a range after a correction.

That caution was particularly relevant after a strong run in coal prices. The restocking window could end before the larger investment thesis did. A pause in buying or a change in inventory needs could produce a pullback without settling the longer-term question.

He identified Core Natural Resources and Peabody as his two key positions. Both offered thermal and metallurgical exposure, which he viewed as a combination of a core business and additional upside if steelmaking coal improved. At that point, he treated HCC, AMR and METC more tactically.

The distinction was portfolio construction as much as stock selection: which names to hold through a cycle, which to trade around it, and how much confidence to place in the next seasonal move.

Energy costs connected the wider commodity discussion

Warder linked natural-gas costs with fertilizer and other industrial inputs, then broadened the discussion to copper, zinc and precious metals. His long-term gold view was constructive, while Parets questioned how much time the metal might need to consolidate after a large advance.

Both recognized that a powerful theme could contain substantial corrections. Warder discussed trimming at important price levels and watching rotation. Parets reconsidered his expectation for a longer consolidation as new momentum appeared. The historical analogies were tools for asking questions, not a schedule the market had to follow.

As Warder put it near the end, "as soon as one thing changes, so does the rest of the landscape." Fuel competition, supply disruptions, input costs and end-market demand were connected, which made ongoing observation more valuable than a fixed narrative.

The same theme could support different trading horizons

Earlier, Parets disclosed a tactical natural-gas position through UNG. Strazza saw the appeal for a trade while pointing to an energy equity as a different way to express a longer-term view. Strazza also held short-dated bond calls and wanted the trade to begin working before extending exposure further out.

Kenny Glick's segment operated on a much shorter clock. He explained a pullback that held VWAP after an initial move, using that reference to define the next attempt. The setup depended on intraday behavior rather than an industry forecast.

Questions and answers

#

From the September 3, 2026 conversation.

Why did Warder separate thermal and metallurgical coal?

Thermal coal is used for electricity generation, while metallurgical coal is used to make coke for steelmaking. Warder linked their rallies to different demand and supply forces, including fuel competition for thermal coal and production disruptions and restocking for metallurgical coal. They were not interchangeable exposures.

Link to this answer

Why did Warder prefer pullbacks despite a constructive coal outlook?

He thought the restocking window was approaching its later stages after a strong rally. A change in inventory demand could produce a correction before the longer-term thesis ended. He separated core holdings from more tactical names and used price ranges to guide potential entries.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .