Takeaways
#- Sohn compared $67 billion of August money market inflows with $7 billion in equity ETF inflows. He watched for a change in which group attracted more new money.
- Parets read weak defensive stocks as favorable for equities; Strazza thought 5% Treasury yields gave some investors another place to seek safety.
- Energy ETF outflows interested Sohn once energy stocks began to outperform. Sokoloff still wanted Chevron to clear and hold $165.
In August 2023, roughly $67 billion flowed into money market funds, compared with $7 billion into equity ETFs, according to Todd Sohn. The part that interested him wasn't how much buying power might someday return to stocks. It was how little enthusiasm equity funds had attracted in a year when stocks had already made substantial gains.
On the September 5 Morning Show, Sohn put money market fund inflows at $769 billion for the year to date. Short Treasury bills offered a yield around 5%. Investors could get exposure through funds such as the SPDR Bloomberg 1-3 Month T-Bill ETF (BIL) or the iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF (SGOV), without taking on the price swings of stocks. Getting paid to wait was an attractive choice in its own right.
JC Parets asked whether all that money on the sidelines would eventually come back and lift the stock indexes. Sohn didn’t think it had to. He recalled the 1990s, when money market assets and stocks had grown together. What he wanted to see was a change in new money: if equity ETFs started attracting more dollars than money market funds, he would pay attention even if the money already in cash stayed there.
Could Treasury bills explain weak defensive stocks?
Consumer staples and low-volatility stocks had been losing ground relative to the broader market. High-yield credit spreads were tight. Parets saw little evidence that equity investors were scrambling to protect themselves. Steve Strazza offered a reason to be cautious about that conclusion: a person who could buy a Treasury bill at 5% didn't have to buy a utility stock and accept the risk that its shares might fall.
The disagreement came down to whose money they were tracking. Parets was thinking of managers whose mandates required them to stay invested in equities. If they wanted a less aggressive portfolio, they might have to buy more defensive stocks. A household with a brokerage account had other choices. As Sohn pointed out, the room to hold cash varied by fund. A manager who stayed in cash during a rally might also have to explain the resulting shortfall to clients. The panel wanted a number it didn’t yet have: how much equity money actually operated under those constraints?
Energy was getting stronger as investors took money out
Sohn had a striking comparison in energy. By his count, about $11 billion had left energy sector ETFs since the start of the year, more than the outflows from the other four sectors with withdrawals combined. Energy stocks had struggled in the first half. By early September he was seeing better relative performance and breakouts in price, even though the year-to-date fund totals still reflected selling. He cared about the outflows because the stocks were starting to give him a reason to look again.
Not every energy stock had broken out. Later in the program, Kimmy Sokoloff singled out Chevron (CVX), which had lagged some other oil names. She wanted it to clear $165 and hold there before looking for a move toward $170. Parets already owned Chevron and was interested in adding. Sokoloff was watching the same company for a shorter-term trade, and she could still see the sellers who had stopped it at $165 before.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-09-05 episode.
Why didn’t Sohn expect all the money in cash funds to return to stocks?
He recalled that money market assets had grown alongside equities during the 1990s. He wanted to see whether new equity ETF inflows could overtake new money market inflows.
What did Sohn see in energy despite $11 billion of withdrawals?
Energy stocks had begun to improve relative to the market after a weak first half. He thought the combination of improving prices and limited investor interest mattered more than fund flows alone.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .