Takeaways
#- Lund treated an ETF closure as a reason to reexamine an unpopular industry, not an entry signal.
- Parets and Thwaites watched Tilray near its old $2.50 lows. Lund distinguished a short-term trade from a small, long-term speculation.
- Strazza wanted evidence that falling selling prices and shrinking margins had stabilized before taking an interest.
Brian Lund remembered what happened when investors gave up on coal. The VanEck Vectors Coal ETF (KOL) was liquidated in December 2020, before a strong run in coal stocks. In 2023, when he heard that the AdvisorShares Poseidon Dynamic Cannabis ETF (PSDN) was closing, he put cannabis stocks back on his screen. His point on the September 6 Morning Show was that a fund closing could tell him where to look. It couldn't tell him when to buy.
The two closures were real business decisions. VanEck’s board had approved winding down its coal fund; three years later, AdvisorShares’ notice gave August 25 as the expected last trading day for its cannabis fund. What Lund needed in the second case was evidence that buyers were returning to the underlying shares. For much of the preceding two years, a sharp rally in cannabis had been followed almost immediately by a retreat. This time the stocks had gone up and kept more of their gains.
What $2.50 meant on the Tilray chart
JC Parets brought up Tilray Brands and pointed to the old 2020 lows near $2.50. If the shares could hold above that area, he had a reference for a long trade. Mary Thwaites, who had already traded in and out of Tilray more than once, later called attention to the same level. The price had briefly slipped beneath support and recovered. She thought a stock that had spent so long falling deserved another look.
Lund drew a distinction between trading that recovery and speculating on the industry’s future. The share prices were low in dollars. That didn’t make the businesses cheap against earnings or assets. His way of pursuing a possible multiyear recovery had been to use discretionary money he could leave alone. A company could still go out of business before that long wait paid off. For a shorter-term entry, he thought the stocks might already be a little ahead of themselves.
A stronger price didn’t settle the margin question
The news included talk of a change in federal cannabis scheduling. Steve Strazza had heard versions of that story for years. What made this rally different? Lund’s answer was the price action: for once the excitement hadn't vanished in a day. Strazza wanted a business reason as well. Producers faced competition and falling selling prices. Tobacco companies had demonstrated the ability to maintain their prices; he hadn’t seen the same thing from cannabis producers.
Lund wondered whether a recognizable brand could eventually command a premium where an undifferentiated crop couldn't. Thwaites pointed to Tilray’s agreement to acquire eight beer and beverage brands as one company-specific development, alongside its recent earnings. Strazza remained unconvinced that a beverage business answered his concern about cannabis margins. Parets and Thwaites still had a price at which to judge their trade. Strazza had a different condition: he wanted the deterioration in margins to stop before he would take an interest.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-09-06 episode.
Why did Lund compare cannabis stocks with coal?
The coal fund had shut near a period of deep pessimism, ahead of a rally in the underlying stocks. He wondered whether the cannabis fund closure marked similar disinterest, but still wanted to see the shares hold a rally.
Did Lund mean cannabis stocks were undervalued?
No. When challenged on the word 'cheap,' he clarified that he meant the low dollar price per share. That was distinct from a low valuation or a claim that a company would survive.
What did Mary Thwaites see in Tilray?
She had traded it before and saw a failed breakdown at an old support area near $2.50. She was watching how it responded to recent company news as well as the wider sector rally.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .