Takeaways

#
  • Johnson's preferred correction toward S&P 500 6,150 to 6,200 was a retest within a continuing larger bull market.
  • His alternative bullish test required recovery above both the 50-day and 20-day averages and improvement in the recent lower-high structure.
  • Johnson and Parets agreed that biotech charts were strong while acknowledging that company events could cause abrupt losses.
  • They disagreed about whether gold and silver strength should be read as a defensive warning for equities.

Craig Johnson thought the S&P 500 might need to revisit 6,150 to 6,200 before offering the next substantial buying opportunity. His November 25, 2025 Morning Show appearance began with the participation data behind that view, then moved to the conditions that could prove him wrong.

Johnson did not think the larger bull market was over. He expected a correction within it. JC Parets agreed that individual stocks making higher lows deserved attention, but questioned whether concentrated leadership and strong precious metals justified the degree of caution Johnson expressed.

Johnson's concern began below the index

Johnson said 28% of the more than 3,500 stocks Piper Sandler followed were already below their April 7 lows. He also reported that only 28 of 416 industry groups were making six-month highs.

Relative performance added to his concern. He described leadership in areas such as gold, silver and shipping, while a larger set of cyclical and technology groups made new relative lows. He did not see participation consistent with an uncomplicated new advance across the market.

His proposed S&P 500 pullback toward 6,150 to 6,200 would revisit an earlier breakout area on the weekly chart. He described that as a normal retest within the longer uptrend, rather than the end of the secular or cyclical bull market.

Parets asked whether the spring selloff had instead reset a new bull-market cycle. Johnson was unconvinced. He looked for a change in leadership when identifying a new cycle and thought technology's continuing importance argued against that interpretation.

A recovery could change his position

Parets asked what would make Johnson accept a year-end rally. Johnson gave two routes back to a more enthusiastic outlook. The first was the deeper pullback he preferred, which would return price to support and reduce some of the market's excesses.

The second was a recovery strong enough to invalidate his immediate caution. He wanted the S&P 500 back above its 50-day and 20-day moving averages, followed by a reversal of the sequence of lower highs established since late October.

Parets noticed that the index was already close to the 50-day average. Johnson clarified that crossing that one reference alone was not his complete test. The higher average and the recent downtrend still mattered.

He allowed that the stronger scenario could lead to another advance into year-end. He simply did not regard it as established during the interview.

They agreed on biotech strength and debated its risk

Parets described concentrating on stocks and groups that had held above their October lows. Biotechnology was an area where he had found many such charts, and Johnson agreed that XBI looked strong.

Their agreement on the trend did not remove the industry's event risk. Johnson cited ATYR as an example of a promising chart that had suffered a severe price decline. He warned that a single company event could overwhelm an otherwise constructive pattern.

Parets explained his own approach: restrict the universe by market capitalization and use a basket of biotechnology stocks. Johnson accepted the reasoning but pointed out that size did not eliminate the problem. A company near that capitalization threshold could still suffer a sharp loss.

The practical agreement was narrower than a blanket endorsement of the sector. Both saw opportunities, while Johnson kept returning to position size and the consequences of individual events.

Gold and international strength produced a real disagreement

Parets then asked how Johnson reconciled his U.S. caution with strong equity markets elsewhere. Johnson emphasized the dollar. He expected its recovery from the lower end of a long-term range to complicate international returns for U.S. investors, particularly where local markets had already advanced sharply.

Their disagreement became more direct on gold and silver. Johnson treated the metals' strength as a defensive signal and questioned whether it fit an optimistic equity outlook. Parets pointed to the recent experience of gold and stocks rising together and rejected the idea that metals strength had to be bearish for equities.

Neither interpretation became a verified outcome during the conversation. Johnson left with a preferred correction scenario and a defined recovery that could change it. Parets continued to favor the strong individual charts he could identify, while accepting that the two were drawing different conclusions from the broader evidence.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-11-25 episode.

Did Johnson think the larger bull market had ended?

No. He described his preferred pullback toward 6,150 to 6,200 as a normal retest inside the continuing secular and cyclical uptrend.

Link to this answer

What recovery would challenge his cautious outlook?

He wanted the S&P 500 above its 50-day and 20-day moving averages and a break in the lower-high sequence that had developed since late October.

Link to this answer

Where did Johnson and Parets disagree on precious metals?

Johnson viewed gold and silver strength as a defensive signal. Parets pointed to stocks and gold rising together and did not think the metals' strength necessarily undermined the equity bull market.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .