Takeaways
#- The team screened its own $1 billion to $4 billion universe for stocks close to new highs. It didn’t wait for a small-cap index to outperform first.
- CONSOL and Alpha stood out as leaders, and Strazza said the team already owned them.
- Strazza’s Peabody purchase was a catch-up trade at support. Options activity drew attention to BTU, but the shares remained range-bound.
Steve Strazza had bought Peabody Energy near support, hoping it would catch up to two coal producers that were already moving higher. Several weeks later, Peabody was still stuck in a range. When unusual options activity put it back on the Morning Show’s screen on August 29, 2023, his preference was for the two leaders: CONSOL Energy and Alpha Metallurgical Resources.
JC Parets and Strazza had found both on a list that might have looked unpromising to anyone following only the Russell 2000. Small caps had yet to start outperforming large caps. But as Parets pointed out to Spencer Israel, the relative performance of an index didn’t say whether one of its stocks was making a new high, or even whether the index itself was rising.
How coal made the list
The team’s screen used its own definition of small: companies worth between $1 billion and $4 billion. Within that group, they looked for stocks trading close to their highs. Energy names had held up through much of the August selling, so more of them had risen to the top of the list.
CONSOL, then trading as CEIX, was making new all-time highs. Alpha Metallurgical Resources, ticker AMR, had a similarly strong chart. Strazza said the team was already long both. Their strength was visible within the group, even without a broad shift from large stocks into small ones.
Owning a laggard didn’t make it the next buy
Peabody offered a different trade: buy at support, then see whether the laggard could close the gap. Strazza disclosed that he had tried it. But the arrival of options activity in BTU hadn’t resolved the stock’s trading range. He said it would look better above $30. Asked to choose among the coal stocks on that morning’s charts, he still preferred the ones trading near their highs.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-08-29 episode.
How did the show define a small cap for this screen?
Parets used a $1 billion to $4 billion market-cap range. It was the team’s working definition for its list, not an eligibility rule for the Russell 2000.
Why had Strazza bought Peabody if he preferred CONSOL and Alpha?
BTU had come down to support, and he hoped it would catch up. Weeks later it was still trading in a range while the other coal stocks remained leaders.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .