Takeaways
#- Schwager argued that mispricing can persist because it is difficult or costly to trade against, using 3Com and Palm as an example.
- A stock can keep rising after a trader judges it overvalued; he discussed waiting for evidence that a bubble has begun to break.
- Flexibility meant revising a position when the facts changed, while patience applied both before entry and during a profitable trade.
- He favored a method suited to the trader’s temperament over copying another successful investor’s decisions.
Jack Schwager did not see a contradiction between markets being inefficient and markets being difficult to beat. A trader could identify an absurd price and still lose money while waiting for it to correct.
That distinction ran through his conversation with JC Parets and Steve Strazza, recorded April 4, 2024 and published April 11. They began with the efficient-market hypothesis before turning to the habits Schwager had encountered while interviewing traders for the Market Wizards books.
A visible mispricing can resist correction
Schwager returned to the relationship between 3Com and Palm during the technology boom. Through its retained ownership, 3Com gave investors an indirect interest in Palm. Yet the market priced that interest inconsistently with Palm’s separately traded shares.
The apparent solution was arbitrage: buy the relatively cheap exposure and sell the expensive one. Schwager explained why that was difficult in practice. Palm shares were hard or expensive to borrow, obstructing the short side of the trade. The same constraint is documented in Owen Lamont and Richard Thaler’s study of technology-stock carve-outs.
For Schwager, the episode challenged the idea that prices always reflected a coherent valuation. It also showed why recognizing an inconsistency did not automatically provide a cheap, executable way to profit from it.
Being right about value does not determine the timing
He identified a separate problem with betting against a bubble. A price that already looked unreasonable could rise much further before reversing. A trader’s eventual assessment could prove correct after the intervening move had made the position impossible to maintain.
Schwager described traders waiting until a bubble had begun to break before acting. That approach gave up part of the move in exchange for evidence that the direction had changed. Trying to identify the final high while prices were still climbing was much harder.
This was also why he rejected a common shortcut in the argument about efficient markets. Evidence that most managers struggle to outperform does not, by itself, establish that every market price is correct. In his view, emotion can create mispricing while also making its duration and extent difficult to predict.
Flexibility meant changing the position when the facts changed
Asked what successful traders shared beyond risk management, Schwager emphasized flexibility. Conviction at entry needed to coexist with a willingness to change an opinion when the market failed to behave as expected.
He contrasted that with continually explaining away an adverse move. A trader could keep finding reasons why a losing position would eventually work, becoming more attached to the original view as contrary evidence accumulated.
Patience mattered in two places. First, a trader needed to wait for opportunities that met the method’s criteria, even when watching a screen made inactivity uncomfortable. Second, a profitable position could require patience too. The temptation to take a quick gain could prevent participation in a much larger move.
The method had to fit the person
Schwager’s interview subjects used radically different approaches. Some concentrated on long-term fundamentals; others relied on charts or short-term execution. He did not interpret those differences as a reason to combine every successful trader’s process.
His own training in economics had initially drawn him toward fundamentals. Over time, he found himself more comfortable with technical analysis. He also said that some of his worst mistakes came from being influenced by someone else’s opinion rather than following an approach that suited him.
Better tools had not removed that problem. Schwager valued easier access to charts, lower commissions and greater liquidity. But he believed futures trends had also become more interrupted by counter-moves, making straightforward trend-following harder. He presented that comparison as an observation worth studying, and explicitly declined to extend the same historical claim to individual stocks, which he had not followed closely in the earlier period.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-04-11 episode.
Why did Schwager think inefficient markets could still be hard to beat?
Mispricing can last longer or become more extreme than a trader expects. Borrowing constraints can prevent an arbitrage, and an overvalued stock can continue rising before it reverses.
What did the 3Com and Palm example illustrate?
Schwager described inconsistent prices for direct Palm shares and the Palm interest embedded in 3Com. The difficulty and cost of borrowing Palm shares obstructed the trade that might otherwise have brought those prices together.
What did he look for beyond risk management?
He emphasized flexibility, patience and a method that fit the trader. His April 4 conversation, published April 11, 2024, distinguished learning from successful traders from trying to copy all of their approaches.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .