Takeaways
#- Franzen saw improving participation among S&P 500 constituents across three high-low time frames.
- He treated the Williams percent R move from oversold to overbought as confirmation of buying strength.
- Narrowing credit spreads supported the equity recovery, while a further low in spreads remained a condition he wanted to see.
- Bitcoin’s relative chart retained support but had made lower highs since March; losing the support range would weaken his outlook.
Caleb Franzen had held his stock exposure through the early-August selloff. He had not bought on August 5 or 6, and he had not added short-term downside protection. He waited for the recovery to develop before buying again that Thursday.
By the August 21, 2024 Morning Show, he thought the evidence favored remaining invested. The speed of the rebound had made some investors reluctant to participate, but he saw broad buying, bullish moving-average relationships and improving credit conditions. Bitcoin required a more qualified answer. He expected it to catch up with stocks, while identifying a relative support level whose failure would concern him.
New highs were outnumbering new lows
Franzen began inside the S&P 500. Across 20-day, 50-day and 52-week measures, more constituents were making new highs than new lows. He regarded that participation as evidence of an uptrend. The improvement extended beyond the movement of the index itself.
His momentum chart used 40-day Williams percent R, an indicator locating price within its recent high-low range. It had moved from oversold to overbought, with the latest signal arriving that Monday. In the roughly two years of examples he was studying, that transition had accompanied the end of pullbacks.
He interpreted the overbought reading as confirmation of demand. An oversold reading alone had been less decisive: conditions could remain oversold while prices continued falling. The subsequent move to the upper end of the range showed that buyers had returned with force.
The moving averages reinforced that view. The S&P 500 was above its 20-, 50- and 200-day averages, with the 20-day above the 50-day and the 50-day above the 200-day. Franzen called that a bull-market characteristic. He allowed for a short-term pullback of roughly 2%, although that was not his base case.
Credit spreads offered another check
Franzen also watched whether the bond market supported the equity recovery. Credit spreads had widened during the scare and then narrowed as stocks recovered. On his chart, he inverted the spread series so that narrowing spreads and a rising S&P 500 moved in the same visual direction.
He interpreted the narrowing as evidence that bond investors perceived less risk. A further low in spreads would increase his confidence that markets were looking through the growth concerns behind the earlier selling. That additional confirmation was still something he wanted to see.
His own response to the volatility had been to leave existing exposure in place and let conditions settle. When he resumed buying, he felt some discomfort about chasing the bounce. He said those additions had worked well so far, but his decision had followed the recovery rather than anticipated its lowest point.
Bitcoin’s relative support mattered more than a catch-up timetable
Bitcoin had not kept pace with the stock-market rebound. Franzen remained optimistic and thought a catch-up move would take time. He pointed to an earlier period when stocks and Bitcoin had diverged before moving together again.
The hosts pressed him on how much divergence he would tolerate. His answer was a chart of Bitcoin relative to the S&P 500, using the ratio’s former high and 2022 low to mark a 50% retracement area. That area had become support.
The picture was mixed. Higher lows supported his constructive view, but lower highs since March were a concern. He estimated that the relative ratio would need to fall about 9% to reach the important support range. That figure described Bitcoin’s performance against the S&P 500, not a 9% stop in Bitcoin’s dollar price.
Franzen would become more concerned if the ratio lost that range. He also allowed for further consolidation, or another test lower, before the larger uptrend resumed. His expectation of a catch-up rally depended on support continuing to hold; the weaker relative chart still needed to improve.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2024-08-21 episode.
Why did Franzen welcome an overbought momentum reading?
The move from oversold to overbought showed renewed demand. He viewed the transition alongside improving breadth and bullish moving-average relationships, rather than treating the overbought label alone as a reason to sell.
What had he done during the early-August decline?
He said he retained his exposure without adding short-term downside protection. He did not buy on August 5 or 6 and resumed buying that Thursday after the recovery had developed.
What did the 9% figure mean on his Bitcoin chart?
It was the approximate distance from the Bitcoin-to-S&P 500 ratio to a relative support range. It was not a dollar-price stop for Bitcoin. Franzen said a loss of that range would concern him.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .