Takeaways
#- Wald tracked the weakest S&P sector’s twelve-month return to assess improving breadth and concentrated weakness.
- The weakest sector was up roughly 6%, below the approximately 15% level he associated with peak breadth.
- Small-cap participation, strong momentum and the advance-decline line supported his preference for buying pullbacks.
- He combined the recent VIX spike and daily RSI reset with the broader evidence, while keeping seasonality secondary to price.
Ari Wald was looking beyond the strongest stocks when he assessed the bull market on July 30, 2024. The weakest S&P sector could tell him something different: how far participation had improved, and whether concentrated weakness was beginning to damage the broader advance.
On the Morning Show, Wald explained that his sector indicator was improving but had not reached the level he associated with peak breadth. Combined with small-cap breakouts and strong market internals, that left him inclined to buy pullbacks rather than treat July as the end of the advance.
What the weakest sector could reveal
Wald’s sector culprit indicator tracked the rolling twelve-month return of the poorest-performing S&P sector. The comparison used the market-cap-weighted sector indexes.
He described two different readings. At the strong end, even the weakest sector gaining roughly 15% over a year represented what he called peak breadth. At the weak end, a sector already down around 20% could confirm serious deterioration and had been associated with below-average subsequent market returns in his research.
The timing mattered. Peak breadth was not necessarily the market’s peak; the index could continue higher for months or quarters while participation began to narrow. Likewise, the negative reading had sometimes served more as confirmation of a developing top than as an early warning.
In the current discussion, the weakest sector was consumer staples, up roughly 6% over twelve months. Wald saw directional improvement without the uniformly strong performance that would put his peak-breadth threshold in play.
JC Parets asked whether the same approach worked for narrower industry groups. Wald had not built that version. He expected its thresholds to differ because industry returns could vary more sharply.
Small caps were contributing to the bullish case
Wald treated small-cap performance as a useful measure of market participation. He liked the simultaneous improvement in growth and value stocks, along with strength across consumer, industrial, financial and other groups. The advance was becoming broader.
He also interpreted strong momentum differently from a simple warning that stocks were overbought. The S&P 500’s weekly relative strength index had recently reached about 77. For Wald, that reflected an acceleration in price, and he considered it alongside the expanding new-high list rather than an automatic reason to sell.
The New York Stock Exchange advance-decline line reinforced that view. Wald said divergences in that measure had preceded many major tops in his historical work, often by months. He was not seeing the substantial divergence he would normally look for before anticipating a major decline.
He explicitly allowed for exceptions. A divergence was not required at every top, and the indicator was not infallible. His conclusion came from the combined evidence rather than a promise from any single measure.
Volatility had created a nearer-term setup
Against that broader backdrop, Wald saw the recent volatility increase as potentially constructive for entries. His approach compared the VIX with its own three-month low, treating a rise of 50% from that low as a spike. The starting level mattered to his interpretation.
He paired that change with a reset in the S&P 500’s daily RSI to its lowest level in three months. The combination suggested a tactical opportunity within the still-favorable broader market structure.
He made an important distinction about the opposite condition: a low VIX alone was not a useful reason to sell stocks, because it could remain low throughout a bull market.
He was still watching the next stage of the cycle
Wald’s positive near-term view did not eliminate his concerns farther out. He discussed the possibility of a market-top scenario over the following twelve months as the cycle matured and monetary policy changed. He did not think the evidence had put the market there yet.
He also cautioned against letting seasonal patterns make the decision. Historical election-year behavior helped him outline possibilities for August, but he wanted price to confirm them. Seasonality was secondary evidence, not a substitute for the trends and participation he was tracking.
Questions and answers
#Questions about the original 2024-07-30 episode.
What did the sector culprit indicator measure?
It tracked the rolling twelve-month return of the weakest market-cap-weighted S&P sector. Wald used it to examine both broad strength and concentrated weakness.
Did peak breadth mean stocks had to top immediately?
No. Wald said the market peak could follow months or quarters later as participation narrowed. He also noted that the negative sector reading sometimes confirmed deterioration rather than leading it.
How did he define the VIX spike he was discussing?
He compared the VIX with its three-month low and used a rise of 50% above that low. He considered the starting level and the broader market evidence, rather than using volatility in isolation.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .