Takeaways
#- Netto expected a larger S&P reaction than in quieter periods and flagged 2 p.m. Eastern as the time a stock-specific move could be mistaken for company news.
- He distinguished a pause at 5%–5.25% from an eventual cut. Futures prices had pared back earlier expectations of easing.
- Short-term bonds and gold were among the markets he wanted to watch for a response. Core PCE and the next wage figures would provide more current inflation evidence.
A trader watching one stock at 2 p.m. could see a sharp move and conclude that something had happened to the company. John Netto had a different explanation to check first. On May 24, 2023, that was the hour the Federal Reserve would publish the minutes of its May meeting. Even someone with no intention of trading the announcement had a reason to know when it was coming.
Speaking by phone on the Morning Show, Netto estimated that the S&P might move 10 to 15 points on the release. In quieter periods, he said, minutes might have been good for a point or two. This time, investors disagreed about what would come after a possible halt to rate increases.
Holding rates steady wasn't the same as cutting them
The minutes due that afternoon covered the May 2–3 meeting. The committee had already lifted its target to 5%–5.25%. Netto's reading of Jerome Powell’s recent appearances was that the Fed might be finished raising rates. He wanted to see whether the written account supported that interpretation. A pause alone would say little about how long the rate might stay there.
Steve Strazza recalled that futures had recently pointed to cuts starting as early as late summer, with several by the end of the year. Some of that expectation had come out of the market. Netto put the remaining amount at roughly one and a half cuts. Nobody was forecasting a literal half decision. Futures prices could reflect several possible outcomes, rather than a single agreed date for the first cut.
To Netto, that difference determined what news was left to trade. If traders already expected rates to hold for a while, a repeat of that message might offer little reason to change positions. Language suggesting the committee might consider easing later in the year could matter even without an immediate policy change.
The reaction he wanted to see in bonds
Shorter-dated fixed income had been under pressure in the preceding sessions, as had gold and silver. Netto thought some of the morning bounce might reflect traders reducing positions ahead of the minutes. A further rally in short-term bonds after language supporting a pause would tell a different story. In that scenario, he thought gold could find some relief too.
JC Parets had been watching the 10-year Treasury yield rise from an area near 3.25%, around its 2018 high. For him, the useful part of Netto’s calendar was knowing when to pay attention to that chart and its effect on other positions. He didn't need to anticipate every sentence in the release.
The meeting had taken place three weeks earlier. Netto had another appointment circled for Friday at 8:30 a.m. Eastern: the next release of personal consumption expenditures data. Core PCE and the wage figures in the following week's employment report could shift expectations again. Those were fresh observations of prices and pay, something no set of minutes could provide.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-05-24 episode.
Which meeting did the May 24 minutes cover?
The Fed published the record of its May 2–3 meeting. The target range agreed at that meeting was 5%–5.25%; May 24 was the release of the minutes, not another rate decision.
What did Netto mean by about one and a half cuts?
He was describing the amount of easing implied by market pricing over possible outcomes. The Fed would still have to make individual decisions at actual meetings.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .