Takeaways
#- Franzen counted S&P 500 members making highs and lows over 20 days, 50 days and 52 weeks. Highs outnumbered lows across all three in the last two weeks.
- MGK had reclaimed its August 2022 high. Losing that level would give Franzen reason to reduce risk in the growth trade.
- Parets had already bought small caps and saw Caterpillar as a way to participate in a rotation toward industrial stocks.
Caleb Franzen and JC Parets could agree that the rally was spreading. Where they wanted their money was another matter. Parets had bought small caps about a month earlier. By June 12, the Russell was trading at a three-month high. Franzen liked what he saw in industrial stocks, but a week or two of better small-cap performance hadn't persuaded him to move away from the biggest growth companies.
Every Friday, Franzen counted how many S&P 500 stocks had reached new highs and how many had set new lows. He did it three times, over 20 days, 50 days and 52 weeks. Three weeks before the show, the short and intermediate counts had been slightly negative: more members made lows than highs. In each of the last two weeks, highs outnumbered lows on all three measures.
There were two ways for those numbers to improve. A rush of stocks could break out, or the stocks under the most pressure could stop registering new lows. The hosts pointed to the second as a big part of the change. Fewer stocks breaking down made the index rally easier to trust. It didn't tell Franzen that its strongest stocks had run out of buyers.
The level he wanted growth stocks to keep
Franzen pulled up the Vanguard Mega Cap Growth ETF (MGK). It had reclaimed the lows it made in January 2022 and the highs it reached that August. The August high gave him a place to reconsider: if buyers couldn't defend a level they'd just won back, there would be a reason to take less risk. Until then, he preferred the group that had already cleared it.
For Parets, some of the opportunity lay in what would have to improve if the advance kept spreading. Later in the broadcast, he explained why he'd liked Caterpillar (CAT) even though other individual charts looked better. In a bull market broadening beyond growth stocks, he expected industrial stocks and smaller companies to attract money. Caterpillar gave him a way to take the industrial side of that view. Sean McLaughlin reported that they'd already sold half their Caterpillar calls.
Two funds, then the stocks inside them
Asked where he'd look for individual stocks, Franzen chose MGK and the iShares Expanded Tech-Software Sector ETF (IGV). He wanted to open up the funds and look at the underlying charts. There was no requirement that he find the next leader in a new industry: the stocks doing most of the lifting could still offer opportunities if their own price trends held.
Franzen left room for another possibility. The biggest growth stocks could give up ground while money moved into other groups. A heavily weighted index could weaken in that environment even as individual stocks elsewhere improved. His August reference on MGK would give him a reason to revisit the growth trade; the weekly counts would help him see whether the weakness had spread.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-06-12 episode.
Why could breadth improve without a wave of breakouts?
Fewer stocks were making new lows. That improved the difference between new highs and new lows even without a comparable jump in the number of stocks reaching highs.
Where did Franzen look for individual stock ideas?
He chose the holdings of MGK, the mega-cap growth fund, and IGV, the software fund. He wanted to examine the charts of the stocks inside each.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .