Takeaways

#
  • Greenberg questioned the supply-chain and execution assumptions behind MP’s future magnet business.
  • Parets wanted a break below $20 and a weaker chart before considering a short position.
  • Greenberg disclosed that he was not invested in MP and acknowledged that headlines or a squeeze could move it against his thesis.
  • In Hims, the debate centered on growth durability and subscriber trends while Parets remained long.

Herb Greenberg’s warning about MP Materials (MP) did not persuade JC Parets to short the stock immediately. Parets wanted to see it fall below $20 and deteriorate around a price reference anchored to its former highs.

Their May 7, 2025 discussion on Stock Market TV put two different decisions side by side: identifying a business risk and choosing when to trade it. Greenberg was investigating what could go wrong underneath a compelling company story. Parets was asking whether buyers or sellers had taken control of the stock.

Greenberg’s concern was the business still to be built

MP Materials had attracted attention as investors looked for domestic sources of rare earths. Greenberg focused on the steps between operating a mine and producing finished magnets at scale.

He questioned the supply of heavy rare earth inputs, including dysprosium and terbium, and the work required to source and process them. He also wanted investors to distinguish existing operations from the future earnings they hoped the magnet business would produce.

The trade disruption was already concrete. In its April 17 announcement, MP said it had stopped shipping rare earth concentrate to China. The company said it was stockpiling concentrate while accelerating oxide production, heavy rare earth separation and magnet production in Texas.

Greenberg’s skepticism concerned the difficulty and timing of that transition. A strategically important industry could still involve substantial execution risk for the individual company. He wanted investors to understand the mining, processing and manufacturing requirements before extrapolating a national supply-chain ambition into future profits.

Parets needed the stock to confirm the warning

Parets said he could see a bullish interpretation of MP above $20. He also watched a volume-weighted average price anchored to the prior highs. While the stock remained above that reference, he was reluctant to take the short side.

Below $20, with deterioration around the anchored VWAP and a developing sequence of lower highs and lower lows, he would become more interested in Greenberg’s bearish case. The research supplied a potential reason for weakness; the chart would determine whether he wanted to act on it.

Greenberg emphasized that his work was not a timing mechanism. He was not invested in MP and recognized that headlines, positioning and a squeeze could push its shares higher despite his concerns. He generally preferred to avoid stocks where strongly opposed investor camps dominated the discussion.

Hims exposed a disagreement over the meaning of growth

The same tension appeared in Hims & Hers Health (HIMS), which Parets said he owned. Greenberg was watching subscriber growth and the durability of the business beneath the enthusiasm for weight-loss treatments.

He was concerned about a slowing subscriber-growth rate, competition and customer-acquisition costs. That was different from claiming subscribers were disappearing: the company’s May 5 results reported nearly 2.4 million subscribers, up 38% from a year earlier. Management also introduced financial targets for 2030, a horizon Greenberg thought investors were relying on too readily.

Parets stressed the gains shareholders had already enjoyed. Greenberg wanted to see whether the company could sustain its operating progress and grow into expectations. He acknowledged the work involved in building the business, but resisted treating a sharp stock-price advance as proof that the execution questions had been settled.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the May 7, 2025 discussion of MP Materials and Hims & Hers.

What would have made Parets more interested in shorting MP Materials?

He discussed a move below $20, weakness around VWAP anchored to the former highs, and a pattern of lower highs and lower lows. He did not treat the fundamental warning as sufficient to enter immediately.

Link to this answer

What part of MP’s business concerned Greenberg?

He focused on the transition from mining rare earths to producing magnets, including input sourcing, processing requirements and the time needed to turn those plans into profits.

Link to this answer

What did Greenberg want to monitor at Hims & Hers?

He emphasized subscriber-growth trends, customer-acquisition costs, competition and the company’s ability to sustain its operating progress. Parets placed more weight on the favorable price trend and his existing long position.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .