Takeaways

#
  • Chicago soft wheat led despite ample U.S. supplies. Setzer took that as a clue that speculative demand was contributing to the rally.
  • Kansas City and Minneapolis wheat had their own supply concerns, including drought in different growing regions.
  • For soybeans, Setzer watched weather against a smaller acreage estimate. For meal, she checked whether physical buyers were paying higher prices alongside futures.

Chicago wheat was leading the rally, and that struck Angie Setzer as odd. The U.S. had plentiful supplies of the soft red winter wheat behind that contract. If an immediate shortage of a particular crop had been driving prices, she'd have looked first to Kansas City or Minneapolis, where the hard wheats had real production problems. On the July 21, 2023 What the FICC, she told Spencer Israel and Ian Culley why she suspected speculators were buying the Black Sea headlines.

Russia had withdrawn from the Black Sea Grain Initiative four days earlier. The agreement had allowed Ukraine to move large volumes of grain by sea. Losing it didn’t make the crop disappear, Setzer explained. It made the same quantity harder and more expensive to deliver. She compared it to moving house: the same belongings take many more trips in a small car than in a truck.

Three contracts, three supply pictures

Setzer worked with soft wheat growers whose crops went into foods such as cakes and cookies. Hard red winter wheat from the southern Plains and hard red spring wheat from the northern Plains and Canadian prairies served different buyers. Drought and abandoned acres had already hurt the southern crop. Dry conditions farther north had raised concerns about spring wheat production. Those problems helped explain why the two hard wheat prices were trading relatively close together.

On Culley’s charts, September Chicago wheat had found sellers around $7.25 to $7.30 a bushel. Kansas City was pressing against roughly $9, while he was watching about $9.05 in Minneapolis spring wheat. He liked the bases forming in the latter two, but wanted to see buyers clear resistance and momentum strengthen before treating either as a breakout.

Setzer didn't dismiss the risk to wheat prices. The July shipping lull gave buyers some breathing room; the route would matter more as volumes increased later in the season. Russian exports could still help meet demand, and she saw little sign that the buyers who actually needed grain were panicking. A transport problem could keep prices volatile without proving the world had already run short of wheat.

Where the crop had less room for error

Soybeans, rather than wheat, were the market Setzer planned to watch most closely the next week. U.S. acreage estimates had fallen. Weaker export expectations had offset some of the effect on projected ending stocks, but a change of even one or two bushels per acre across the crop could materially alter what remained. A forecast for temperatures near 100 degrees in Des Moines made the accompanying rainfall forecast particularly important. Heat alone wasn’t a crop failure. If the forecast held and rain stayed away, she thought November soybean futures could move toward $14.50 or $15 a bushel.

Culley preferred the soybean oil chart to soybean meal. Setzer had a different reason for watching meal: it went into animal feed, and a rise in the price that an exporter or feed buyer would pay for the actual product told her something a futures quote alone could not. Stronger cash prices in major exporting countries alongside stronger futures could indicate tighter supplies or increased demand. If futures jumped while the people using the product paid no more for it, she looked harder at trading volume, open interest and the role of speculative money.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-07-21 episode.

Why did the loss of the Black Sea corridor matter if grain was still available?

Setzer said large vessels had been the cheapest, most efficient way to move it. Alternative routes could carry less grain per trip, especially as seasonal shipping volumes picked up.

Link to this answer

What did Setzer look for in a soybean meal rally?

She compared futures prices with prices for actual meal in exporting markets. Strength in both was more persuasive evidence of demand or a supply shortage than a futures rally alone.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .