Takeaways

#
  • Thompson treated repeated moving-average crossings cautiously because the market had been trading sideways.
  • Both speakers saw improving breadth, but neither described it as a decisive expansion in participation.
  • Healthcare and retail illustrated how industry composition and index weighting could change the apparent message.
  • Software, homebuilders and a potential Russell 2000 breakout supplied specific tests for their next assessment.

A sideways S&P 500 could accommodate several competing stories. On the November 14, 2025 edition of Thompson's Two Cents, Larry Thompson and guest JC Parets worked through the evidence for rotation within a bull market and the warning signs that could undermine it.

They agreed that the major indexes had not suffered a decisive collapse. They also wanted broader participation before treating every bounce as a fresh advance. Their differences concerned how much weight to give weak industries, defensive leadership and improving breadth that had yet to become forceful.

Moving averages needed the right conditions

Thompson began with the market's sideways behavior over the preceding month. Repeated crossings of a moving average could produce a series of frustrating signals when price was moving within a range.

He used the average directional index, or ADX, to help distinguish a stronger trend from a less directional environment. Its purpose in the discussion was to inform how he interpreted other signals. A moving-average crossing in a choppy market did not deserve the same confidence as one within a sustained trend.

Parets agreed that moving averages were not magic. Both treated them as context for price behavior rather than automatic support or resistance.

That distinction carried into their assessment of large technology stocks. The equal-weighted MAGS fund had suffered a failed breakout, but its larger pattern still looked sideways. A range that had not yet broken down was different from a completed top.

Breadth had improved without delivering a thrust

Parets returned to September 11, when the NYSE advance-decline line and the percentage of stocks above their 200-day moving averages had peaked. That date helped him compare the industries that had advanced during the internal correction with those that had weakened.

Thompson wanted the recent improvement in participation to become more convincing. The share of stocks above their short-term moving averages had not produced the strong expansion he wanted since mid-September. A rebound concentrated in a few areas could leave the broader market vulnerable.

His breadth approach also depended on the larger environment. A washed-out reading during an established uptrend could offer different information from the same reading during a bear market. He did not treat every oversold condition as a buying signal.

Parets acknowledged that improving breadth was not yet a decisive thrust. More time might be necessary. For him, a convincing Russell 2000 breakout would provide particularly useful evidence that participation was expanding beyond the largest companies.

Sector labels and index weights changed the picture

Healthcare leadership prompted a familiar disagreement. Thompson noted its defensive associations and recalled earlier periods when its relative strength had accompanied a weaker market. Parets pointed to speculative biotechnology companies making multiyear highs, which he did not interpret as investors simply hiding in dependable businesses.

Retail supplied a second example of why composition mattered. Thompson had become more neutral on XRT after its breakout failed. Losing a bullish development mattered even if it did not immediately create a bearish trade.

Parets was less persuaded by retail as a broad market gauge. Strong and weak companies could coexist within the group, and the better appearance of the capitalization-weighted RTH compared with equal-weighted XRT showed how the weighting method affected the result. He preferred to give more weight to the Dow's strength.

Software and homebuilders could decide the next move

Thompson saw software reaching a cluster of potential support references, including the April anchored volume-weighted average price and its 200-day moving average. That location complicated the case for pressing fresh shorts. A support test was still unresolved.

He also watched potential failed breakouts in high-beta versus low-volatility stocks and consumer discretionary versus staples. Those ratios could help show whether investors were becoming less willing to take risk. He cautioned that several technology-heavy comparisons could repeat much of the same information.

Asked what would make him more bearish, Thompson pointed to software failing, semiconductors following it lower and the largest technology stocks breaking their range. Parets added the possibility of further weakness in homebuilders, including the ITB and XHB charts discussed earlier.

Their bullish tests were equally concrete. Thompson wanted homebuilders to reject a breakdown and follow through above their 200-day moving average, alongside a software recovery and better risk-appetite ratios. Parets wanted small caps to break out convincingly.

The market had not supplied those answers yet. Rotation remained Parets' preferred interpretation, while Thompson wanted stronger participation to support it. Both left room for the next set of prices to change their assessment.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2025-11-14 episode.

Why did Thompson want more than an oversold breadth reading?

He wanted participation to recover convincingly and considered the larger market trend. The same washed-out reading could behave differently in a bull market and a bear market.

Link to this answer

Why did XRT and RTH tell different stories?

The equal-weighted XRT had suffered a failed breakout, while the capitalization-weighted RTH looked stronger. Their different weighting methods emphasized different parts of retail.

Link to this answer

What would have strengthened the bullish case?

Thompson wanted homebuilders to reject their breakdown, software to recover and risk-appetite ratios to improve. Parets wanted a convincing Russell 2000 breakout as evidence of broader participation.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .