Takeaways
#- Gold futures had held the 2011 peak longer in 2023 than in either of the two earlier attempts Culley compared.
- Culley used a daily front-month futures close below $1,900 to judge a possible short; $1,923.70 was his longer-term reference.
- Mining shares had lost ground even as the metals held their June lows. Gold’s gain relative to bonds did little to change that assessment.
The number on Ian Culley’s gold futures chart was $1,923.70 an ounce. It marked the 2011 peak, a high that took nearly a decade to regain. Gold spent two months above it in 2020 and just one in 2022. By August 2023, it had managed five, even as rising real interest rates made bonds a more attractive alternative to a metal that paid no interest.
That was encouraging, Culley told Spencer Israel on the August 23 edition of What The FICC. What he wanted to know next was whether investors were willing to buy the companies that mined the metal. Their charts gave him little reason to rush.
The level Culley would trade against
Culley kept the old high on his monthly chart. For a decision about the next trade, he went to the daily chart of the front-month futures contract. A close below $1,900 would put him off owning gold and make him consider a short. That gave him a way to act even if the usual relationship between gold and real yields failed him.
He had a historical example of why it might. From 2004 into 2007, he said, real yields rose about a percentage point and a half, yet gold gained roughly 77%. Rising yields mattered to him in August 2023, especially with the dollar rebounding. They couldn’t tell him on their own whether the gold trade had failed.
Where the miners had already broken down
Gold and silver were still holding their June lows. The VanEck Gold Miners ETF, GDX, had lost its June low of $28.76. On Culley’s table of moving averages for the Philadelphia Gold and Silver Index, every reading from five to 250 days was red. A strong day for the metals hadn’t reversed that weakness in the stocks.
Culley showed Israel a chart where gold did look strong: SPDR Gold Shares against the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF. The ratio had reached a new high. Later, a viewer asked whether that said more about gold or bonds. The hosts leaned toward weakness in bonds. Gold could beat long Treasuries without attracting the sort of buying Culley wanted to see in mining stocks.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-08-23 episode.
Why were there two different prices on Culley’s gold charts?
The $1,923.70 level was the 2011 high on his monthly chart. On the daily chart he used a front-month futures close below $1,900 as a reason to consider a short.
What did GDX show that the metals didn’t?
The miners ETF had fallen below its June low of $28.76. Gold and silver themselves were still holding their June lows.
What did a new high in gold relative to long Treasuries mean?
GLD had outperformed TLT. When a viewer asked what drove the move, the hosts saw weakness in bonds as the bigger explanation.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .