Takeaways

#
  • Culley saw orange juice as an advanced trend with no easy fresh entry; a tight consolidation or a defined pullback setup would be more useful.
  • For sugar, he preferred a decisive break above 27.88 cents per pound toward a possible 31.50 objective.
  • Feeder cattle’s break below 248 had already occurred, so he looked for a rebound toward that level or a new bearish continuation pattern.
  • A parabolic advance could first lose momentum and consolidate before breaking down, as the earlier coffee move illustrated.

Orange juice kept climbing, but Ian Culley was finding it difficult to identify a new entry. Sugar offered a possible continuation trade. Feeder cattle had already broken down from a topping pattern.

On the October 27, 2023 What The FICC, Culley and Spencer Israel compared those markets to show how differently a commodity trend could look before, during and after a steep advance.

Orange juice was strong but difficult to enter

Culley described the orange-juice rally from the 2020 lows as a parabolic advance. The price had accelerated as the move matured, leaving an increasingly steep trendline beneath it.

Israel asked what would tell him the advance was running out of steam. Culley wanted to see that trendline break. He also watched the weekly RSI, which was near 80; a fall back below 70 would suggest the possibility of a pause.

A mature trend could still continue higher. That did not give Culley an easy entry at the existing price. He would be more interested if the market paused, formed a tight flag or pennant and then resolved higher. Alternatively, a trader needed a defined way to buy a pullback.

Coffee supplied a comparison. Its earlier surge had eventually given way to a long consolidation and then a breakdown. Culley emphasized that a sharp commodity advance did not always reverse in one immediate plunge; the pattern could first lose momentum and move sideways.

Sugar still offered a continuation setup

Sugar had advanced from an earlier consolidation and then spent several months digesting the move. Culley found the resulting pattern more useful for a prospective trade than the extended orange-juice chart.

He outlined two approaches: buy weakness toward 26 cents per pound or wait for a decisive break above 27.88. He preferred the latter, with an objective around 31.50. Those prices use the cents-per-pound convention for raw-sugar futures.

He was less interested in settling on a perfect pattern name. The boundaries sloped, which made the formation harder to trade. A clear breakout level gave him a more practical decision than arguing over whether the consolidation resembled an inverted head-and-shoulders pattern.

Israel added a lesson from his own sugar position: a compelling chart did not necessarily mean the chosen vehicle would move as quickly as he expected. He had found the day-to-day changes frustratingly small.

Feeder cattle had already crossed the warning line

Feeder cattle illustrated the other side of a steep advance. Culley saw a daily head-and-shoulders top and said the break below 248 cents per pound had been the short signal. By the broadcast, the market had moved toward 235.

He acknowledged that he had not been on top of that initial break. His next preference was to sell a rebound toward the former neckline around 248. If that recovery did not arrive, a short flag or pennant could provide another setup.

His first downside objective was around 220, with 200 and possibly 190 as further areas to watch. He also noted the first oversold momentum reading since October 2020 as evidence that the character of the trend was changing.

The rebound entry and the continuation pattern were alternatives. Culley was looking for a new place to define the short after the original breakdown had already happened.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-10-27 episode.

What would warn Culley that orange juice was losing momentum?

He watched for a break of the steep trendline and for weekly RSI to fall back below 70 from its elevated reading. Those would point to a possible pause in the advance.

Link to this answer

Which sugar entry did he prefer?

He considered buying a pullback toward 26 cents per pound, but preferred a decisive breakout above 27.88. His possible upside objective was around 31.50.

Link to this answer

What was his plan after missing the feeder-cattle breakdown?

Culley wanted a rebound toward the broken neckline around 248 cents per pound to consider a short. A bearish flag or pennant could supply an alternative. He identified 220 as an initial objective, with lower areas around 200 and 190.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .