Takeaways
#- Gold had not broken out to a new all-time high during the recording; Culley was watching for a move above $2,100.
- He viewed silver outperforming gold as a sign of greater risk appetite within precious metals.
- His stock selection favored miners showing strength against their peers, including Alamos and Kinross.
- He still wanted GDX to outperform the broad equity market and silver miners to outperform silver.
Gold was near its old highs, but Ian Culley was careful about what had happened and what had not. In the November 29, 2023 What The FICC episode, he told Spencer Israel that gold had yet to break out to a new all-time high. A move above $2,100 would strengthen the case he was building.
His interest extended beyond gold’s price. He was watching silver’s performance against gold, mining stocks against the broader equity market and individual miners against their peers. Those comparisons would help him judge whether the rally was attracting wider participation.
Silver was part of the gold argument
Culley treated silver as the more aggressive part of the precious-metals trade. When silver outperformed gold, he saw it as evidence of greater willingness to take risk within the group. That made the silver-to-gold ratio relevant even to someone focused on gold.
The absolute charts still needed to clear their own levels. Silver futures were challenging a multiyear downtrend, and he identified $26.50 as a threshold that could open the way toward higher prices.
Gold’s ETF chart had progressed further in his assessment. For SPDR Gold Shares, he focused on $185.50. With GLD above that level, he favored the long side and discussed $240 as an upside objective.
Mining stocks were at different stages
Culley distinguished the broad mining ETF from some stronger individual names. VanEck Gold Miners ETF had reached a three-month high, rather than the fresh yearly highs seen elsewhere in the group. He considered GDX’s recovery above $30 encouraging, but still saw potential resistance around $33 and $36 before a longer-term objective near $45.
Alamos Gold was one of his preferred individual stocks. He highlighted its recovery above $13 and discussed $20 as an objective. He also watched Kinross Gold above $5.50, with a possible move toward $11 to $11.50.
His selection process emphasized strength against other mining stocks as well as the broader market. Buying a gold miner was not enough for the approach he described; he wanted names outperforming the mining benchmark. He also acknowledged that nearby resistance could produce a messy consolidation even after a breakout.
The relative-strength checks were still unfinished
Toward the end of the discussion, Culley returned to the evidence that still needed to improve. Gold itself had not made the decisive breakout. GDX’s relative performance against the S&P 500 was only beginning to turn up after a fresh yearly low, and he wanted to see sustained outperformance.
He also monitored the Global X Silver Miners ETF against iShares Silver Trust. He wanted the miners to gain ground against silver itself. The ratio had found support, but he did not claim that a repeat of an earlier precious-metals rally was assured.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-11-29 episode.
What gold level was Culley watching?
He identified a move above $2,100 as a stronger confirmation signal. Gold had not yet reached a new all-time high during the recording.
Why did he compare silver with gold?
He considered silver the more aggressive part of the precious-metals trade. Silver outperforming gold suggested greater willingness to take risk within the group, which supported his bullish interpretation.
What mining-stock comparisons was he watching?
He compared individual miners with GDX, GDX with the S&P 500, and the SIL silver-miners ETF with SLV. He wanted the riskier parts of the group to strengthen relative to their alternatives.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .