Takeaways

#
  • Shuchart saw the Russian fuel export restriction as a potential opening for U.S. diesel refiners as winter approached.
  • Culley identified $93.25 as the nearer crude-oil test, with roughly $115 a possibility if price cleared it.
  • A reserve release could add barrels temporarily; Shuchart’s longer-term concern was the rate at which new supply was being developed.
  • She expected the energy transition itself to require energy-intensive mining and saw long lead times for large nuclear projects.

Crude oil had reached a familiar price on Ian Culley’s chart: $93.25 a barrel. Tracy Shuchart, founder of Hilltower Resource Advisors, thought a move through $100 was possible. But when Culley asked about the spread between crude and the products made from it, she had a more specific answer. A shortage of diesel could benefit companies that turned crude into fuel, even before oil broke through its next level.

The two were speaking with Spencer Israel on the September 22, 2023 edition of What The FICC. Oil services stocks had been leading the energy sector. Russia’s announcement restricting gasoline and diesel exports gave Shuchart a reason to watch for a change in that order.

The price of a barrel versus the price of its products

Culley was watching the crack spread. For diesel, that compares the wholesale price of the finished fuel with the price of the crude needed to produce it, expressed in the same units. It gives a sense of the margin available to a refiner before its other costs. A rising oil price by itself tells you little about whether that margin is widening.

Shuchart said the spreads had come off their highs but still looked elevated by historical standards. She had reduced her interest in refiners as the spreads narrowed. The Russian export restriction changed her assessment: buyers seeking replacement fuel could turn to U.S. refineries. She saw winter demand ahead for heavier fuels and a recovery in Asian jet fuel demand as international travel resumed.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration had already raised its diesel price forecast that September, citing stronger August diesel crack spreads and expectations for lower fall inventories. Shuchart’s interest was in which businesses might capture the difference between a tight market for refined products and the cost of their crude.

Why $93.25 mattered to Culley

Culley placed crude inside a broad range from roughly $62.50 to $115. Former highs from the early 2010s helped explain the upper boundary. At $93.25, though, he had a more immediate test. The level had provided support after oil’s 2022 spike, then acted as resistance later that year. With crude back there, he thought a break above it could bring $115 into view.

Shuchart accepted the possibility of $115 without welcoming a spike. Higher energy costs made other goods and services more expensive too. When Israel asked what news might move the price, she distinguished a potential U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve release from additional production. A release announcement could push the price down. It wouldn't add new wells or expand refining capacity.

The longer wait for supply

Over the following five to seven years, Shuchart considered a return to a sustained $40–$50 oil range unlikely. Demand was still growing, in her view, while years of insufficient capital spending had left producers with too little supply in development. Mining the metals needed for new energy infrastructure would consume energy well before the finished projects could deliver it.

A viewer asked how quickly nuclear power could help. Shuchart pointed to the time between proposing a large plant and putting it into service: in her experience, permitting and construction together could take ten to fifteen years. She thought smaller modular designs offered a chance to shorten that wait.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-09-22 episode.

Why did Shuchart revisit refiners after pulling back?

Refining spreads had narrowed, but Russia’s restriction on gasoline and diesel exports changed the supply picture. She thought U.S. refiners could serve buyers seeking replacement diesel.

Link to this answer

How did Culley arrive at $93.25 for crude?

He identified it as an area where price had previously found support and later met resistance. A new break above it could open the way toward the upper part of his chart range, around $115.

Link to this answer

Why didn’t Shuchart consider an SPR release a lasting fix?

It could temporarily increase available barrels and affect price, but it would not address the years of underinvestment she saw behind the longer-term supply problem.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .