Takeaways

#
  • Christians saw broader participation as support for the bull market without treating it as proof of a lasting leadership change.
  • His July 5 breadth reading used a 21-day window and a historical proxy before 1957.
  • He wanted improving relative rankings before increasing exposure to lagging groups.
  • Optimism and election seasonality were secondary to a combination of trend, breadth and credit evidence.

Dean Christians welcomed the expanding participation in stocks on the July 22, 2024 Morning Show. He thought it strengthened the bull market. What he would not do was immediately declare that technology had surrendered leadership to small caps and value.

More companies could rise without replacing the strongest groups. Christians, a senior research analyst at SentimenTrader, wanted the new contenders to improve against the S&P 500 over more than a brief burst of activity.

A rebound from an unusually narrow market

Christians brought a measure of how many S&P 500 members had outperformed the index over 21 trading days. On July 5, that figure had fallen to 14%, the lowest reading in his historical series. A handful of large companies had been pulling the benchmark ahead of most of its constituents.

He explained a limitation of the long comparison. The series reached back to 1928, but the S&P did not expand to 500 companies until 1957. For the earlier period, his research used a proxy consisting of the 500 largest stocks by market capitalization.

The recent improvement was, in his view, a reaction to that extreme concentration. Investors had crowded into large technology stocks while leaving other groups behind. A sharp recovery in the average stock made sense. It still needed to persist before he would call it a durable leadership change.

Absolute gains were not enough for an allocation change

Christians continued to give technology the benefit of the doubt on his medium- and long-term relative measures. Financials, industrials and small caps were improving, but the rankings had not yet established a new order.

Asked what would make him want more small-cap exposure, he pointed directly to those rankings. Small-cap financials had recently reached a positive score in his work. He wanted similar evidence of sustained relative strength before becoming more enthusiastic about the wider group.

He was also cautious about assuming that lower inflation automatically meant the problems facing smaller companies had disappeared. Expectations for easier monetary policy had improved, but the interest-rate burden had not changed overnight.

When leadership became unclear, Christians described a way of reducing the size of the decision. Rather than keeping a concentrated technology or semiconductor allocation, he might move closer to the S&P 500 while the competing trends developed. That was his meaning of becoming more neutral: staying closer to the benchmark while taking less sector risk.

Steve Strazza was more willing to favor the laggards. Later in the program, he argued that the Dow could outperform the S&P 500 and Nasdaq in the second half of the year, and favored the Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP) over the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY). Christians’s earlier interview required more confirmation before making that kind of relative commitment.

Optimism alone was a weak reason to call a top

Sentiment remained elevated in Christians’s composite. That did not surprise him in a bull market. His attempts to build risk-off signals from optimism had been less useful than signals built around extreme pessimism that subsequently reversed.

For a potential market peak, he wanted several developments to agree: weakening breadth, optimistic sentiment beginning to turn down, and possible deterioration in credit. A high sentiment reading on its own did not meet that standard.

That approach also shaped his treatment of the presidential election cycle. He placed seasonality in the third or fourth tier of indicators and asked whether it confirmed the actual trend. A tendency toward softer or sideways trading before the election was secondary to the breadth and price evidence in front of him.

Questions and answers

#

Questions about the original 2024-07-22 episode.

Why did Christians distinguish broadening from a leadership change?

More stocks could participate in a rally while technology continued to lead on medium- and long-term relative measures. He wanted the improvement in other groups to persist and strengthen their rankings against the S&P 500.

Link to this answer

What did becoming more neutral mean in his example?

He described potentially moving from a concentrated technology or semiconductor allocation toward the S&P 500. That would keep him closer to the benchmark while leadership became clearer.

Link to this answer

How much weight did he give election seasonality?

He treated it as a third- or fourth-tier indicator and asked whether it agreed with trend and breadth. A seasonal tendency alone did not override those measures.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .