Takeaways

#
  • Parets dated the turn to when more individual stocks stopped making lows, rather than the day the S&P 500 reached its closing low.
  • New one-month and one-quarter highs gave Parets evidence of a recovery before stocks had regained their annual highs.
  • Zarling favored the benchmark as leadership narrowed and added individual positions as participation improved and entries appeared.

JC Parets was celebrating the bull market’s first birthday on June 16, 2023. Anyone looking at the S&P 500 chart had an obvious objection. The index closed at 3,666.77 on June 16, 2022, then sank to 3,577.03 on October 12, according to S&P Dow Jones Indices’ daily series. Why start the clock four months early?

Parets was counting stocks. Through June and July of 2022, bad news kept arriving, but more of the individual charts he followed had stopped going down. By the time the index set its October low, he saw relatively few stocks still making fresh lows of their own. June was his date for that change in participation. October remained the low for the benchmark.

The highs list that could move first

Once stocks stopped falling, Parets wanted to know how many could sustain a rally. A stock that had just endured a deep decline might need months to get within reach of its 52-week high. Requiring a new 52-week high would miss much of the early move.

He and Steve Strazza also kept lists of stocks reaching highs for the past 21 and 63 trading days, roughly a month and a quarter. Those shorter lists had expanded in January 2023. The annual highs list was picking up by June. Later in the episode, Parets showed the S&P 500 advance-decline line, which accumulates the difference between the number of rising stocks and falling stocks. He said it had closed at a new high the previous day. A handful of giant companies can pull a capitalization-weighted index higher; they don't get extra votes in a count of advancing issues.

Zarling could see the turn without getting an easy entry

David Zarling, who helped manage client portfolios and had developed the Adaptiv Select ETF (ADPV), accepted June as a defensible date on Parets’ terms. His experience between June and October had been less tidy. A stock would break above a level and then come all the way back to test it. Being right about the direction of the larger market didn't make those positions easy for his team to hold.

Zarling described market breadth as an accordion. When fewer stocks participated, he moved toward the benchmark. A capitalization-weighted index already gave its biggest winners more influence, and it spared him the task of finding each one in advance. As participation broadened, he could add individual positions when their charts offered entries. A surge in breadth that January and the reversal in financial stocks that March had tested both sides of that approach.

Argentina offered a June example of what he wanted before acting. Its stocks had broken from a base, paused and formed a short consolidation. Against the benchmark, their relative chart had also turned higher. Two rising charts earned a closer look. Where he could buy, and whether he could stay with the position on a retest, were still separate decisions.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-06-16 episode.

Did Parets think the S&P 500 had bottomed in June 2022?

No. He acknowledged its October low. June was his judgment about when the selling in many of its individual stocks stopped.

Link to this answer

Why did the same period look different to Zarling?

His team had to execute and hold the trades. A breakout followed by a full retest could make a position difficult even as fewer stocks set new lows.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .