Takeaways

#
  • Parets used two different small-cap comparisons to test whether regional-bank weakness depended on the index he chose.
  • Weitzel distinguished fewer stocks making highs after the December rally from an expanding list of stocks making lows.
  • Weitzel watched for a reversal in crowded U.S. growth and short-China trades; Culley’s stronger-dollar view complicated the international case.

When Spencer Israel challenged JC Parets to explain why a particular small-cap chart mattered, Parets put up a second one. His first compared small financial stocks with the S&P SmallCap 600. His second compared regional banks with the Russell 2000. Different indexes, different constituents, much the same picture: the banks were losing ground even against other small companies.

On the February 26, 2024 Morning Show, that distinction mattered to two different investors. IWM tracked the Russell 2000, which included roughly 230 regional banks by Parets’ count. Someone picking individual stocks could leave those banks alone. In 2023, he said, small industrial, technology and consumer discretionary stocks had managed to outperform even when the Russell looked weak. In early 2024 the problem had spread. Small-cap technology was making fresh relative lows against an index that was itself going sideways to down.

Fewer leaders, but few new lows

Stephen Weitzel, a portfolio manager visiting the show for the first time, took a different starting point. Fewer stocks were reaching new highs than in December, when participation had been unusually broad. Yet the list of new lows hadn't expanded. To Weitzel, that left room for money to move between groups without a broad decline.

Amazon and Google were approaching prices where they had run into resistance in 2021. Large-cap growth had edged to a new high against large-cap value, but the weekly momentum chart showed a divergence. Weitzel wanted to see whether the relative breakout would hold. Parets pressed him on what even a successful rotation might mean for index investors. A gain in an industry with a small weight in the Nasdaq could do little to offset a loss in technology. Individual opportunities could multiply without sending the index much higher.

The crowded trade on the other side of the world

Weitzel had been getting emails from fund companies pitching emerging-market portfolios that excluded China. Those portfolios had benefited from avoiding a weak market. What interested him was the timing of the pitch. A fund-manager survey he brought to the show listed owning the biggest U.S. growth stocks and shorting China as its two most crowded trades.

For either trade to unwind, China didn't have to become an attractive economy overnight. Weitzel suggested that an improvement from terrible conditions to merely bad ones could move prices if enough investors had already positioned for the worst. Parets noted that China had reached a six- or seven-week high relative to the S&P 500. For Weitzel, the harder test was whether the S&P’s much longer breakout against emerging markets would reverse.

Ian Culley raised a complication for that overseas scenario. Weitzel thought a broader move abroad would need a weaker dollar. Culley favored a stronger dollar, especially if European or Canadian policymakers started cutting rates before the Federal Reserve.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2024-02-26 episode.

Why did Parets care about banks when discussing IWM?

The Russell 2000 contained roughly 230 regional banks by his count. Their performance mattered more to someone buying that index than to a stock picker who could avoid them.

Link to this answer

What would make the China idea more convincing?

Weitzel wanted evidence of a broader reversal in relative performance. China had improved against the S&P over several weeks, but the S&P still had a much longer record of outperformance against emerging markets.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .