Takeaways

#
  • Parets owned Bitcoin and had bought two sets of January calls on Marathon Digital, at $14 and $30 strikes.
  • Marathon was already at his $20 objective even though Bitcoin hadn’t broken out. He was weighing the planned exit against waiting for the original Bitcoin thesis.
  • Pearlman saw a gap between a market’s turn and investors’ willingness to act on it. A sideways stretch could ease an extended market without a deep decline.

JC Parets bought calls on Marathon Digital because he wanted more exposure to a Bitcoin rally. By the morning of July 14, 2023, the miner was near his $20 target, but Bitcoin hadn’t broken out. The trade had worked faster than the idea behind it. Parets told Spencer Israel he still hadn’t decided whether to sell before the weekend.

The position had grown out of a limit he’d set for himself. Below $31,000, he felt he owned as much Bitcoin as he was prepared to hold. He already had January $14 calls on Marathon; when he wanted more upside exposure, he bought January $30 calls as well. A move in the miner mattered much more to his account than it would have if he had simply held the cryptocurrency. He described the previous day as the most profitable of his trading career, but gave some of the credit to luck: he hadn’t expected the miners to run that far while Bitcoin stood still.

The temptation to change an exit

If someone had shown him Marathon and Coinbase’s gains in advance, Parets said, he would have guessed Bitcoin was already trading in the mid-$30,000s or higher. Instead, its trading range had narrowed. A quieter market gave him reason to expect a larger move, with no guarantee about direction. It was the strength of the stocks around Bitcoin that made him favor an upside break.

The question for the Marathon calls was whether to take the profit he’d planned or wait for the move in Bitcoin he’d originally bought them for. Looking at Marathon on its own favored the first choice. Looking at what Bitcoin might still do made the second appealing. As he left the broadcast, the decision was still open.

A rally can change minds before it changes portfolios

Phil Pearlman saw another kind of lag. Investors who had spent months expecting a bear market were starting to worry about missing a bull market. He pointed to the Nasdaq 100: people had worried about how far it had climbed above its moving averages, yet four weeks of sideways trading had given it time to digest those gains. People still had to decide whether they believed the change and whether to buy.

Pearlman described himself as a long-term investor who kept buying in stronger and weaker markets. He had made an occasional tactical bet, including buying small caps after discussing them with Parets. What interested him about that July rally was how long it could take someone else to reach the same decision. A bearish investor could stop expecting prices to fall well before feeling ready to put money to work.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-07-14 episode.

Had Parets sold the Marathon calls by the time he left the show?

He had reached his target but said he hadn’t decided what to do. He was still weighing the miner’s gains against the possibility of Bitcoin following it higher.

Link to this answer

Why didn’t Pearlman expect sentiment to change overnight?

The rally first challenged investors’ bearish expectations. Then they had to decide whether a higher market justified actually buying. Pearlman thought those decisions could unfold over time.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .