Takeaways
#- Importing Instagram connections gave Threads an audience on its first night. Israel wanted to keep his personal contacts separate from his markets feed.
- Elfenbein recalled how blogs let investors publish their work and discuss it directly with readers, without going through an editor.
- Parets’ earlier Meta options had expired; he wanted the stock below $290 before considering a short.
Spencer Israel had a rule for Instagram: he wanted to follow people he actually saw a couple of times a year. Twitter was where he went to work. When he opened Threads on its first night, the feature that made signing up so easy was also the one he liked least. His Instagram friends could find him in a place where he expected to talk markets.
On the July 6, 2023 Morning Show, Israel and JC Parets compared notes after trying the text app that Meta’s Instagram team had just launched. Israel could bring over the accounts he followed on Instagram. What he couldn't do was choose a feed of just the people he wanted to read. He missed direct messages, useful search and a desktop version. He thought the first night’s reported 10 million sign-ups were impressive. Turning that audience into a place he’d use during his working day was another matter.
Why the existing market conversation was hard to move
For Parets, Twitter’s appeal had been meeting strangers with whom he already shared an interest. He had a particularly good example that morning. Steve Strazza and colleagues were in Singapore meeting people they knew through the financial community online. Strazza called in later to describe sitting down with investor Jim Rogers in a bakery. The crew put away its camera. After talking for more than an hour, Rogers invited them to his home for an interview the next day.
Eddy Elfenbein, author of Crossing Wall Street, remembered the change that preceded financial Twitter. He started his blog around 2005 after reading Barry Ritholtz. A writer with an observation about a company no longer had to persuade a journalist and an editor to publish it. Readers could go straight to the writer, look at the data and argue in the comments. Israel already had those kinds of professional connections on one platform. Importing an address book from another wouldn't reproduce them.
The app had just launched. The stock had already rallied.
When they returned to the Meta chart, Israel wondered whether Threads would give the shares much of a lift that day or the next. Parets asked why the launch should count as fresh information for a stock that had already come so far. On the monthly chart, the fall and recovery formed a steep V. He traced the start of the rebound to the period when the U.S. 10-year Treasury yield stopped climbing and buyers began returning to growth stocks.
Parets had traded the rebound with options and described it as his largest dollar gain on a trade. Those options had expired the previous month. His target had been around $290, where the shares filled an earlier price gap. He was interested in a short if Meta dropped below that level. With the stock above it as they spoke, he had neither his old long position nor the new short. The first night's sign-ups hadn't changed his price.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-07-06 episode.
What did Spencer Israel find missing when he tried Threads?
On launch night he couldn't set up the feed he wanted, use a desktop version or message someone directly within Threads. The bigger problem for him was mixing his personal Instagram circle with the professional network he used on Twitter.
Was JC Parets still long Meta when Threads launched?
No. His options on the recovery had expired in June. He said $290 had been his gap-fill target and that he would consider the short side only below that level.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .