Takeaways
#- Settle used 50-day breadth tactically and 200-day breadth to assess how stretched participation had become.
- Parets distinguished extreme S&P 500 breadth from a broader NYSE measure that still had room to improve.
- Settle watched for sustained deterioration in QQQ's relative trend, while acknowledging that other sectors could continue working.
- He wanted gold's own trend to deteriorate before taking a bearish view, rather than shorting it because the dollar was rising.
David Settle saw strong participation in the stock market's advance on March 25, 2024. His chart showed more than 80% of S&P 500 stocks above their 200-day moving averages, the strongest reading he had observed in the cycle.
JC Parets wanted to widen the sample. The equivalent measure for the New York Stock Exchange had not yet surpassed its December high. An extreme in the large-cap index was not necessarily an extreme across the wider exchange.
Two breadth measures served different purposes
Settle used the proportion of stocks above their 50-day moving averages for more tactical decisions. He watched that breadth measure relative to its own 20-day average for changes in bullish or bearish behavior.
The 200-day measure answered a slower question: how stretched had participation become in either direction? He compared the current strength with earlier periods when unusually broad advances had eventually given way to corrections.
His comparison with October 2023 also separated different kinds of weakness. Breadth had deteriorated then, but he had not seen the same expansion in daily ranges or volatility associated with more distressed market lows. The subsequent rally had been forceful despite starting from a less severe decline than the market experienced in 2022.
Parets' objection concerned the universe behind the chart. Restricting the sample to the S&P 500 described large American companies. Expanding it to the NYSE could show that participation still had room to improve. The two observations did not have to produce the same conclusion about exhaustion.
The largest growth companies were another test
Settle also examined the Nasdaq-100 ETF QQQ relative to the S&P 500. Its earlier relative advance had lost momentum, and the ratio was approaching its 200-day moving average.
Simply reaching that average had not stopped stocks from advancing. Settle distinguished that condition from a break followed by a sustained relative downtrend. He thought the latter would make it harder for the broad index to maintain its recent pace.
Parets raised an alternative: energy, materials and other groups could continue working while the largest growth stocks cooled. Settle agreed that individual sectors could outperform, including during a weaker market. His concern was their ability to replace the largest companies' contribution to a capitalization-weighted index.
That brought the discussion back to the definition of the market. An index weighted heavily toward a few large companies could struggle while investors still found advances elsewhere. Parets distinguished concentrated index weights from a market in which only a handful of stocks were producing positive returns.
A familiar relationship was not a trade signal
Earlier in the interview, Settle had made a similar distinction about relationships between asset classes. The dollar, commodity prices and interest rates had risen without derailing the stock market.
He cautioned against treating a relationship learned from an earlier period as a fixed rule. A correlation could remain negative while becoming much weaker. Two assets that often moved in opposite directions could both have constructive price trends over a particular interval.
Gold was his example. He would not short it solely because the dollar was rising. He wanted to see gold's own uptrend break before turning negative on the metal or related stocks.
The yield curve produced another disagreement. Settle thought the prospect of future rate cuts had helped sustain risk appetite and worried more about the eventual return to a positively sloped curve. Parets asked whether historical patterns would hold in the different environment they had just described. Settle acknowledged that the unusually deep and prolonged inversion was outside his own career experience.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-03-25 episode.
Why did Settle and Parets reach different conclusions about breadth?
They were discussing different stock universes. Settle's S&P 500 measure was unusually strong, while Parets said the broader NYSE measure remained below its December high.
What concerned Settle about QQQ's relative chart?
Its relative momentum had weakened as the ratio approached its 200-day moving average. He thought a sustained break below that reference would create a harder environment for the large-cap index, while other sectors could still outperform.
Would a stronger dollar make Settle short gold?
He said it would not be sufficient on its own. He wanted to see gold's own uptrend break before turning negative on the metal or related stocks.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .