Takeaways
#- Clissold grouped easing cycles by the pace of cuts in the first year, with four or fewer in the slow group.
- Averaging fast cycles could hide drawdowns because the declines began at different points after the first cut.
- He distinguished stocks rising less than the index leaders from stocks actually falling, and saw small-cap growth outperforming small-cap value.
A trader expecting six Federal Reserve rate cuts might sound more bullish than one expecting three. Ed Clissold heard a bearish assumption buried in the larger number: what would have to go wrong for the Fed to cut that fast?
On the March 4 Morning Show, the Ned Davis Research strategist showed the S&P 500’s average path before and after the first cut in an easing cycle. Taken together, the episodes painted a fairly encouraging picture for stocks. Split them by how often the Fed cut in the first year, though, and the reasons to own stocks looked quite different.
What the average concealed
In Clissold’s slower group, the Fed cut four times or fewer over a year. Policymakers could ease conditions without having to race a deteriorating economy. Stocks tended to do well in those circumstances. In faster cycles, a fifth or sixth cut might tell investors more about the severity of the trouble than about the benefit of the extra liquidity.
The problem with averaging the fast cycles was timing. A bear market starting two months after one first cut and a bear market starting a year after another would not show up as a clean drop in the same place on the average chart. Clissold pointed to the aggressive easing around the dot-com bust and the financial crisis. In 1998, by contrast, the Fed had been able to cut a few times amid the Long-Term Capital Management crisis. Stocks had room to advance beyond that episode.
Clissold didn’t assume the Fed would deliver its preferred pace in 2024. Economic trouble could force it to move faster. But investors anticipating aggressive cuts needed an economic scenario to go with the rate forecast.
A smaller share of gains wasn’t a loss
JC Parets raised a related question about the strength of the stock market. More indexes were making highs, but on some measures fewer stocks were participating than during the late-2023 rally. Clissold started with the denominator: when nearly every stock rises in the first leg, the share rising can hardly improve. Small caps had pulled back early in the year, but he hadn’t seen widespread breakdowns.
He paid closer attention when the pattern repeated: the index rallies, participation fails to confirm, a pullback follows, and the next rally has the same problem. December’s breadth readings had made new highs for the bull market. One weaker reading after that left room for another expansion.
Clissold applied the same test to the argument that seven large stocks accounted for too much of the S&P 500’s gain. Companies with large index weights contribute more when their shares rise. An industrial stock that gained less than a technology leader was still going up. A market in which the industrial stock and its peers were actually falling would tell him something different.
One place he was looking for growth beyond the largest companies was within small caps. The hosts noted that the Russell 2000 Growth Index had just reached a two-year high relative to its value counterpart. The small-cap index as a whole didn’t have to outrun the S&P 500 for that change in leadership to matter.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2024-03-04 episode.
Why did Clissold prefer a slower easing cycle for stocks?
A measured pace suggested the economy could tolerate it. Rapid cuts had often come in response to economic or market stress.
What kind of breadth divergence concerned him?
He looked for repeated rallies that fewer stocks confirmed. A step back from unusually strong December participation, without widespread breakdowns, was less troubling.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .