Takeaways
#- Franzen attributed the miners’ weak performance partly to dilution and the approaching Bitcoin halving.
- His options comparison illustrated sensitivity to Bitcoin’s price; mining shares did not have the contractual expiration he used in the analogy.
- He was building a basket gradually and described a six-to-twelve-month holding period.
- Strazza questioned repeated equity issuance, a concern Franzen acknowledged while favoring the potential upside.
Caleb Franzen saw an opportunity in a gap he described between Bitcoin and mining shares: Bitcoin was near its highs for the year, while many miners remained far below theirs. Steve Strazza wanted to know whether repeated share issuance made the miners a poor way to participate in the rally.
That disagreement shaped Franzen’s November 20, 2023 Morning Show interview with Strazza, JC Parets and Spencer Israel. Franzen was already buying a basket of miners, while acknowledging the pressures that had kept their shares from following Bitcoin higher.
The approaching halving complicated the trade
Franzen linked the weakness to share dilution and the approaching Bitcoin halving, expected in April 2024. The halving reduces the newly issued Bitcoin awarded per block, as explained in Bitcoin’s mining glossary. That change affects the mining business directly.
He described mining shares using an options analogy: a bet that would become much more attractive if Bitcoin reached roughly $40,000 to $50,000. He likened the approaching halving to an expiration date that made waiting uncomfortable. The shares themselves had no such contractual expiration; it was his way of explaining their sensitivity to Bitcoin’s price and the mining outlook.
The hosts pressed him on why the stocks had participated earlier in the year but were lagging now. Franzen pointed again to the shorter time until the halving and the additional shares some miners had issued. His thesis required a stronger Bitcoin price to overcome those concerns.
Buying gradually, with dilution still a concern
Franzen said he had begun adding to a basket every day or every other day. He expected to spend about two months building the positions and then hold them for six to twelve months. He saw no need to complete the purchases immediately.
Strazza questioned the pattern of companies raising more equity when their shares rose. Franzen acknowledged the concern, but gave more weight to the potential response to a higher Bitcoin price.
Franzen also described a lesson from his broader crypto trading that year. His journal suggested he had repeatedly exited positions too early. He wanted to give strong trends more room, while explicitly cautioning against abandoning risk management.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-11-20 episode.
Why did Franzen think Bitcoin miners had lagged?
He pointed to additional share issuance and the approaching halving. His thesis was that higher Bitcoin prices could improve the outlook enough for the mining shares to catch up.
How was he building the trade?
Franzen said he was adding to a basket every day or every other day over roughly two months, with an intended holding period of six to twelve months.
What concern did Strazza raise?
Strazza questioned miners that repeatedly issued shares as their stock prices rose. Franzen acknowledged that dilution was a concern, but continued to favor the trade’s sensitivity to a higher Bitcoin price.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .