Takeaways

#
  • Netto read the 336,000 payroll increase alongside softer wage pressure and a 3.8% unemployment rate, which was unchanged from August.
  • With the S&P near 4,245, he wanted to buy lower at 4,237, 4,230 and 4,225 while selling a bounce in five-year Treasury futures.
  • Baiynd wanted TLT to stop making weekly lows, clear about $88 and hold a subsequent pullback around $85 before she committed meaningful size.
  • For equities in a wide range, she favored buying a tested floor and exiting when the rebound failed to break resistance.

The September jobs report had just landed, both stocks and bonds were selling off, and John Netto wanted to take opposite sides of their next moves. His plan on the October 6, 2023 Morning Show was to buy the S&P lower and sell five-year Treasury futures if they bounced.

The headline was strong enough to explain the first reaction. Employers had added 336,000 jobs, roughly twice the estimate discussed on air. Traders had reason to consider whether the Federal Reserve could keep raising rates. For Netto, that still left a question: did a strong labor market mean the same thing for corporate earnings as it did for bond prices?

Three numbers behind the initial selloff

Netto looked at payroll growth, wages and unemployment separately. The establishment survey counted jobs on employers’ payrolls; the household survey supplied the unemployment rate. Those figures could send different signals.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics release available that morning put unemployment at 3.8%, unchanged from August. Average hourly earnings for private nonfarm employees rose 0.2% in September. Netto regarded the wage reading as softer than the jobs headline suggested.

He also pushed back when the hosts wondered whether payrolls would simply be revised away. The two previous months had been revised upward in this release. That did not settle what would happen to September’s estimate, but it gave him little reason to assume an immediate reversal of the surprise.

He wanted lower stock prices to buy and higher bond prices to sell

With the S&P around 4,245 during the discussion, Netto identified 4,237, 4,230 and 4,225 as levels where he wanted to buy. He was willing to let the initial selling come to him rather than take a full position at the first quoted price.

His thesis was relative. Strong employment with less pressure from wages could be a more tolerable outcome for companies than for fixed-income investors still pricing the possibility of further rate increases. Even if equities finished lower, he thought they might recover part of the decline while bonds continued to struggle.

On the Treasury side, he wanted to sell a rebound in the five-year contract. He was looking for liquidity in opposite directions: stock sellers willing to meet his lower bids and bond buyers willing to meet his higher offers.

Baiynd wanted the bond chart to stop making lower lows

Anne-Marie Baiynd, who joined later, approached the Treasury selloff through the weekly chart of the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT). She had seen buyers repeatedly try to catch a low. Their willingness to buy a dip had not prevented the fund from moving lower.

She laid out three conditions before she would commit meaningful size. First, TLT needed to stop breaking to new lows on the weekly chart. Then she wanted it to clear resistance around $88. Finally, she wanted a pullback that held around $85. During the broadcast she said that sequence was nowhere in sight.

Baiynd expected broad equities to trade through a potentially large range. One camp was positioning for more downside; another saw fourth-quarter seasonality and oversold conditions as reasons to buy dips. Their competing orders could produce sharp intraday reversals that tested apparent support in both directions.

Her own approach was to buy where a floor had held, then leave if the rebound could not break resistance. She would consider returning on another successful test of the floor. A market could travel a long way during the day without giving her a reason to stay for a sustained trend.

Questions and answers

#

Questions answered in the original 2023-10-06 episode.

Why did Netto think stocks could outperform bonds after a strong jobs report?

He thought strong employment with softer wage pressure could be tolerable for corporate earnings. Bond prices faced a more direct challenge if investors anticipated further increases in interest rates.

Link to this answer

What would have made Baiynd more willing to buy TLT?

She wanted the weekly decline to stop, resistance around $88 to break, and a subsequent pullback to hold near $85. Repeated dip buying alone did not satisfy those conditions.

Link to this answer

How did Baiynd manage a long trade inside a range?

She looked for a floor that held. If the bounce could not break resistance, she would exit and wait for another test of support rather than continue to hold for a breakout.

Link to this answer

Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .