Takeaways
#- Brown thought energy stocks’ resilience during a substantial oil decline mattered as crude challenged the top of its 2023 range.
- Exxon and Chevron made up close to 40% of XLE by the figures shown that day. Brown preferred oilfield services on relative strength.
- Culley wanted oil to hold above $83.50 before treating $100 as a plausible next level.
On the first trading day of September 2023, crude oil futures had just posted their highest monthly close since the previous October. One detail on the monthly chart caught Steve Strazza’s eye: several times, oil had fallen toward $70 only for buyers to push it back up before the month ended. After three straight monthly gains, crude was testing the other side of its range.
Scott Brown, who covered equities and fixed income for financial advisers, had spent the downturn watching something other than the price of a barrel. Energy stocks had gone sideways while the commodities they produced had suffered steep declines. He thought investors had learned something from what hadn’t happened to the shares. Now oil was pushing through $83 to $84, the upper end of its 2023 range, and he liked the chances for energy stocks in the back half of the year.
Two very different ways to own the energy sector
JC Parets pulled up the Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLE). Exxon Mobil accounted for about 21% and Chevron another 18.5%, according to the figures the hosts read that morning. Someone buying the fund was putting close to 40 cents of every dollar in those two companies. Parets liked Exxon’s own chart: the stock appeared to be emerging from a base, giving a buyer a level nearby against which to judge the trade.
Brown saw another opportunity within the sector. Exxon and Chevron were holding up, but they were among the weaker names relative to their energy peers. Brown preferred the oilfield service companies, particularly SLB, which he referred to by its former name, Schlumberger, and Baker Hughes. If energy kept advancing, he thought the more aggressive names stood to benefit more. A positive view on oil didn't settle which part of the business he wanted to own.
The choice of starting point also changed how much of the move appeared to be behind them. A three-year sector chart showed energy up roughly 180%, against about 46% for technology. Parets acknowledged that three years was an arbitrary window, though its beginning happened to coincide with Exxon’s removal from the Dow. On a chart that went back to 2008, energy was still below an old high. A huge gain off the 2020 lows and a long wait for a breakout could describe the same market.
The level Ian Culley wanted to see hold
Brown remembered a similar move through the low $80s in late 2021. Oil and energy stocks had recovered from a market setback while consumer discretionary stocks had struggled. He wondered whether higher fuel costs might again put pressure on that part of the market. He didn’t think it ruled out individual stocks: when asked for two names he liked, he paired SLB with Amazon, whose shares had just broken out.
Later, Parets asked Ian Culley how far the crude rally might run. Culley brought the conversation back to $83.50. His case for $100 required oil to clear the shelf of prior highs and stay above it. He wasn’t prepared to put a year-end deadline on that move while the breakout was still a work in progress.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-09-01 episode.
Why did Scott Brown prefer oil services to Exxon and Chevron?
The two large integrated companies had held up, but Brown saw stronger relative performance among oilfield services names such as SLB and Baker Hughes. He preferred those if the sector continued higher.
What did a move above $83.50 mean to Ian Culley?
It was the area of earlier highs that had repeatedly stopped crude. A move through and hold above it would give him a case for $100; he didn’t commit to that happening in 2023.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .