Takeaways
#- Roughly 90% of the stocks Lundgren tracked after weekly pattern breakdowns remained below their breakdown prices.
- The S&P 500 held 3,800 through the bank failures, a stronger result than Lundgren said he would have predicted.
- A turn up in his quarterly breadth gauge would prompt him to cover the remaining shorts and add to the long positions he already owned.
David Lundgren already owned the stocks he wanted. He could see industrial companies leading, and he had watched the S&P 500 absorb a run of bank failures without breaking 3,800. Yet when JC Parets asked what would make him retreat from his bullish view, Lundgren corrected the premise. His hedge fund still had a small short position. What he was waiting for was a reason to remove it.
The occasion for the question was a milestone: the S&P 500 had risen 20% from its low, enough to earn a fresh round of bull-market headlines. Parets thought the market had been giving investors that message for months. He was watching how many stocks were reaching 52-week highs on the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq. If the rotation into industrials continued, he expected those lists to get longer.
The stocks still below their breakdowns
Lundgren measured something different. He tracked individual stock trends over four time frames. On his weekly charts, he looked at stocks that had broken down from recognizable patterns and asked where they were trading relative to the price at which each breakdown occurred. Roughly 90% were still lower. A market in which breakdowns tended to stick didn't look to him like one in which he could safely dispense with every hedge.
Other evidence pointed the opposite way. He compared consumer discretionary stocks with staples, high-beta stocks with their quieter counterparts and copper with gold. Looking back at the first months of 2023, he saw those relationships starting to turn before the bank failures reached the headlines. And there was the test at 3,800. Had someone told him about the coming failures in advance, he said, he'd have expected that S&P support to break. When buyers held it, he trusted the result over his own prediction.
A short wasn't a long position in reverse
Lundgren gave Parets an example from the way he managed winning trades. If a stock he owned rose 30%, he might consider adding. His approach depended on capturing the occasional investment that could multiply in value, and taking profits merely because a position was already profitable could cut that opportunity short.
When a stock he was short fell 20% or 30%, his instinct was to cover. A company could lose all of its equity value, but the stock itself could decline no further than zero. A rally against his short, on the other hand, had no equivalent ceiling. That difference mattered more to him than how similar the two trades might look on inverted charts.
Lundgren built his sector rankings from the stocks up, weighting them equally. Industrials had been first or second in that work for more than a year. Construction, engineering and the equipment needed for new factories gave him places to look for sustained winners. He didn't need another watchlist before putting more money to work. He needed his quarterly breadth gauge to turn up. If it did, he said, he'd cover the shorts and increase the long positions he'd already chosen.
Questions and answers
#Questions answered in the original 2023-06-09 episode.
Why did Lundgren treat profitable shorts differently from profitable longs?
He wanted to leave room for a long position to multiply. On a short, the stock could only fall to zero, while a rally against him had no natural upper limit. He was willing to cover after declines of 20% or 30%.
Where did his stock-by-stock work find leadership?
Industrials had ranked first or second for more than a year on his equal-weighted measures. He linked strength in construction and engineering names to spending on factories.
Adapted by Stock Market TV Editorial from the original video. Source date: . Article published: .